6.2. SR 02-07-2011Elk REQUEST FOR ACTION
River
TO ITEM NUMBER
Ci Council 6.2.
AGENDA SECTION MEETING DATE PREPARED BY
Worksession Februa 7, 2011 Tina Allard, Ci Clerk
ITEM DESCRIPTION REVIEWED By
Consider Changing Non-Mayoral Appointment Term Lori ohnson, Ci Administrator
Expirations REVIEWED BY
ACTION REQUESTED
Council direction on whether to proceed with preparing ordinance amendments for the six non-Mayoral
appointment commissions in order to change the term expirations from the last day of February to the
last day of December.
BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION
Currently, the three Mayoral appointment boards (EDA, HRA, and Library Board) have terms that expire
on the last day of December. The six non-Mayoral appointment commissions (Energy City, Heritage
Preservation, Ice Arena, Parks and Recreation, Planning, and Utilities Commission) have terms that
expire on the last day of February.
In conversations the city administrator has had with the Mayor, they have decided to bring this item to
the Council for consideration. The request is to discuss changing the expiration dates of the non-Mayoral
appointments to the last day of December in order for all of the boards and commissions to have the
same expiration dates. It should be noted that the term expirations for the non-Mayoral appointments
were amended in January 1999. Please see attached minutes for background on that change.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Term expirations are set in city ordinance. There would be six ordinance amendments with an
approximate publication cost of $550-600.
ATTACHMENTS
^ January 11, 1999 Council minutes
Morton by Second by Vote
Follow Up
N:\Public Bodies\Boards\Council Memos\2011\Term 1;xpirations.docx
City Council Minutes
January 11, 1999
Page 5
• December 7, 1998, Council meeting: "That any board or commission that has the
ability to recommend or propose a tax levy or fee increase allow only residents of
the city of Elk River on the board or commission."
Councilmember Farber indicated concem in the matter of the Ice Arena /
Commission being included in the residency requirements. He stated thattt{e Ice
Arena Commission is more complicated due to its relationship with You~Hockey,
and that the issue should be tabled to be presented at a future mee~irig allowing
for public input. He further noted that he would not be opposed fo~the residency
requirement if the Ice Arena Commission were excluded. ~.-'
City Attorney Peter Beck indicated that Council may am~rid the city code with
respect to each commission in separate ordinance ar~ndments, or amend the
ordinance with astraight-across-the-board residenpji requirement. In either event,
he advised staff to prepare draft ordinance amendments to be reviewed by
Council at a future meeting.
Councilmember Motin indicated that when seeking board and commission
applicants, there could be a lack of qualified or interested Elk River Residents. He
stated that there may be highly qualified non-resident business owners in the city of
Elk River that (under a residency requirement) would be disqualified.
COUNCILMEMBER THOMPSON''MOVED TO DIRECT STAFF TO PREPARE AMENDMENTS
TO THE CITY CODE FOR EACH BOARD AND COMMISSION REGARDING RESIDENCY,
REQUIRING MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION TO BE A RESIDENT OF THE CITY OF ELK
RIVER AND TO ALLOW,.CURRENT NON-RESIDENT MEMBERS TO BE GRANDFATHERED-IN
• TO ALLOW THEM TO,.jFULFILI THEIR CURRENT TERM, AND SERVE ONE MORE TERM ON
THAT BOARD OR COMMISSION; AND THAT THE ORDINANCE AMENDMENTS BE
BROUGHT BACK'TO THE CITY COUNCIL FOR ACTION AT A FUTURE MEETING, AND THAT
COUNCIL TA~CE PUBLIC INPUT AT THE MEETING IN WHICH THE ISSUE IS DISCUSSED.
COUNCILMIMBER DIETZ SECONDED THE MOTION.
Councilmember Motin indicated that he would prefer to see a preference shown
in tfle city's ordinance for residency, but not a total disqualification.
THE MOTION CARRIED 3-2. Mayor Klinzing, Councilmembers Dietz and Thompson
voted aye. Councilmembers Motin and Farber• voted nay.
5.8. Discuss City Commission and Board Agoointment P
Councilmember Motin discussed his concern with the current expiration of terms,
and the timing of interviews and appointments to commissions and boards. He
suggested making amendments to the policy in order to have consistency in the
dates of expiration, interviews, and appointments. He indicated that in order to
achieve consistency, it should be ensured that interviews and appointments are
made at the beginning of each year, rather than at the end of the year. This
would allow the new Council to be involved in the interviewing and appointment
process.
COUNCILMEMBER MOTIN MOVED TO APPROVE THE PREPARATION OF ORDINANCE
AMENDMENTS REQUIRING ALL COMMISSION AND BOARD MEMBERS TO BE
• INTERVIEWED AND APPOINTED IN THE MONTH OF JANUARY, AND TO REVIEW THE
DRAFT ORDINANCE AMENDMENTS AT THE JANUARY 25, 1999, MEETING.
City Council Minutes
January 11, 1999
Page 6
• COUNCILMEMBER FARBER SECONDED THE MOTION. THE MOTION CARRIED 4-0-1.
Councilmember Dietz abstained.
City Administrator Pat Klaers suggested that a policy statement be included in the
Board/Commission revised policy stating that the City Council reserves the right to
reappoint without interviewing. He suggested that staff prepare a draft policy to
be presented for review at a future meeting.
,.
' 5.7. Consider Board and Commission Appointments
`~_ 5.7a. Plannina Commissi~
.:ILMEMBER DIETZ MOVED TO REAPPOINT JOSEPH SCHUSTER AND LOUISE
R TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION, EACH FOR A THREE (3) YEAR TERM
JG ON DECEMBER 31, 2001. COUNCILMEMBER MOTIN SECONDED THE
N. THE MOTION CARRIED 5-0.
5.7b.
COUNCILMEM$lrR DIETZ MOVED TO REAPPOINT LANA HUBERTY TO THE PARK AND
RECREATION COMMISSION FOR A THREE (3) YEAR TERM EXPIRING ON DECEMBER 31,
2001, WITH NO AC~JON TO FILL DANA ANDERSON'S TERM EXPIRATION UNTIL AFTER THE
RESIDENCY DISCUSS~N AT THE JANUARY 25, 1999, MEETING. COUNCILMEMBER
THOMPSON SECONDE'Q THE MOTION. THE MOTION CARRIED 5-0.
5.9. Human Resource Issues
• 5.9a. Environmental C
City Administrator Pat Klass advised the Council that if there were no
concerns expressed, effect January 12, 1999, Environmental and Code
Enforcement Officer Laurie M era-Kerr will begin work on a part time basis
versus her current full time statu z
5.9b. Liquor Store Manager
City Administrator Pat Klaers informedjt{ie Council that Liquor Store
Manager Fritz Dolejs will be refiring effe ive January 29, 1999, and that his
letter of resignation has been received~e indicated a need for
advertisement for the manager position, a~ the approval of the Council
to begin interviewing for an acting liquor sto a manager. Pat stated that in
discussion with current Assistant Liquor Store Hager Mike Donais, Mike
expressed no interest in the position or in being he acting liquor store
manager. He added that the interviewing and 'ring process is expected
to take approximately three months, and that tw full time clerks, Brent
Behms and Steve Tillmann, have expressed interest both the acting liquor
store manager position and the liquor store manage osition. Pat also
suggested retaining Fritz's services on a short term bass as a consultant.
Councilmember Thompson stated he felt that the assistan liquor store
manager should accept the responsibilities of the interim li or store
• manager position.