6.1 EDSR 10-20-2014 Elk Request for Action
River
To Item Number
Economic Development Authority 6.1
Agenda Section Meeting Date Prepared by
General Business October 20, 2014 Colleen Eddy, Economic Development Specialist
Item Description Reviewed by
Nominate an EDA member to the Public Art Jeremy Barnhart, Deputy Director CODD
Installation Judging Panel
Reviewed by
Action Requested
Nominate a member of the Economic Development Authority to the Public Art Installation Judging
Panel.
Background/Discussion
The Public Art Installation Request for Proposal (RFP) process, as approved in July included the
formation of a judging panel who will evaluate and rank all submitted proposals received. The panel will
consist of five representatives from the City Council, EDA,Parks and Recreation Commission,Arts
Affiance and a resident-at-large. Panelists will make a recommendation to the EDA who in turn will
recommend to the Council,who will have final decision.
Staff anticipates a need of three meetings in order to complete the evaluation process. Panelists will
review the process and schedule meetings accordingly. The goal of the RFP is to complete the evaluation
process by the end of December and announce the winner at the first Council meeting in January,with
installation in the Spring of 2015.
Financial Impact
N/A
Attachments
• Public Art Installation Request for Proposal
POWE11ED BY
Template Updated 4/14 NATURE
Request for Proposal
for a
"Powered by Nature"
Public Art Installation
in the City of Elk River, MN
Registration Due Date/Time
September 8, 2014
4:00 p.m. (CST)
Proposal Due Date/Time
November 6, 2014
4:00 p.m. (CST)
City of Elk River& Economic Development Authority
13065 Orono Parkway
Elk River, MN 55330
POWERED 8Y
NATURE
1
Request for Proposal for a
"Powered by Nature" Public Art Installation
in the City of Elk River, MN
Section 1. General Information
This document solicits Requests for Proposal (RFP) for a "Powered by Nature" Public Art
Installation for the City of Elk River,Minnesota.
RFP Administration
Address all correspondence, requests for additional information, registration, and proposal
submissions to:
Brian Beeman
Economic Development Director
City of Elk River
13065 Orono Parkway
Elk River,MN 55330
bbeeman @ElkRiverMN.gov
763.635.1000
Deadlines
Registrations will be accepted until 4:00 p.m. on September 8,2014.
Proposals from registered artists will be accepted until 4:00 p.m. on November 6,2014.
Acceptance of Proposal Contents
The contents of this RFP will be included in the contract between the selected artist and the EDA.
All information in the proposal is subject to disclosure under the provisions of Minnesota Statutes
Chapter 13—Minnesota Government Data Practices Act.
Section 2: Background
In 2011 the EDA contracted with ChandlerThinks on a Brand Plan for the City of Elk River.
The brand plan identified a brand promise, tagline and creative interpretations for the brand.
The plan also included recommended strategies for implementation, which for the most part
have been completed. Since September of 2011 staff has been working diligently to roll out the
brand. A steering committee was assembled to help implement the brand plan which consisted
of email signatures,letterhead,business cards,and other marketing materials.
Economic Development staff established a brand steering committee to share ideas on ways to
promote the brand plan on a more permanent and larger scale. The steering committee, which
included staff members from Administration, Parks and Recreation, Utilities, and Economic &
Community Development, developed ideas to create a memorable,impactful addition to the city
2
of Elk River landscape that would promote the Powered by Nature Brand, and the City in a
tangible way. Through this process, a number of ideas were developed and refined. EDA staff is
recommending a design competition for a solar powered clock, fountain, tree, or sculpture to be
placed on city property in the city. All items met the brand guidelines set out in the 2011
ChandlerThinks Brand Study available at http://clkmcrnm,rcov 'I) ) unkilt(:enter/V'icw,/293 .
EDA staff felt this project is a unique opportunity to engage the arts community in a project
while developing a long lasting amenity for the city.
Section 3: Overall Scope of Services
What does the City of Elk River and "Powered by Nature" mean to you? The Economic
Development Authority is seeking an impactful, memorable Project that communicates this
concept to current and potential residents, businesses,and visitors.
1. Participatory Process — Artists located within 100 miles of the City of Elk River, MN are
asked to develop a mock up, rendering, or sample of a solar powered clock, fountain, tree,
sculpture or other public art installation ("Project") as an entry into a Request for Proposal
that promotes the concept of"Powered by Nature" and the City of Elk River. Entries may
include photographs, drawings or renderings no larger than 24" x 36", or modeled on a base
no larger than 2'x 2'.
2. Background— In 2011 the EDA contracted with ChandlerThinks on a Brand Plan. As most
of the plan implementation has been complete, the EDA is soliciting interest in a Project
that will be displayed within the City limits and will define the City's Powered by Nature
brand.
3. Locations and Maintenance — Artists will be required to analyze and suggest the best
possible location for the Project so that it will enhance tourism and economic vitality, as well
as consider future maintenance needs and costs.
4. Vision & Overview — Project submissions must promote the concept of "Powered by
Nature".
a. Innovation—Create a Project that defines "Powered by Nature".
b. Economic Development — Create a Project that enhances the City's economic base
and tourism.
c. Judging — The panel of judges will choose a winner to complete their Project. The
panel will include a representative from the City Council, EDA, Parks and
Recreation Commission,Arts Affiance,and a resident at large.
d. Purchase of Project — The selected artist will be compensated up to $12,000 for its
Project, which shall cover transportation and materials costs and an honorarium to
the selected artist.
e. Location of Project — Project submissions must recommend a location on City
property to install the Project. City property includes but is not limited to:
i. City Parks: Rivers Edge Commons, Woodland Trails, Lions John Weicht
Park, Youth Athletic Complex, Dave Anderson Youth Complex, Orono
Park
• 3
ii. City property: 50 Main Street, City Hall (13065 Orono Parkway), Library
(13020 Orono Parkway), Activity Center (413 Proctor), Chamber of
Commerce building (509 US Highway 10).
f. Future Maintenance—Define future maintenance costs to keep the Project attractive
and safe. Project maintenance and associated maintenance costs will be further
defined in a meeting with the Artist.
g. RFP Timeline:
i. Registration. All participants must register their interest in submitting a
proposal by September 8, 2014. Registration is mandatory and a pre-
requisite to submitting a Project proposal.
ii. Proposals, renderings, mock ups, samples of the Project are due by
November 6, 2014. Proposals will be presented to the Judging Panel in
November and December of 2014 and may include photographs, drawings,
or renderings no larger than 24" x 36", or modeled on a base no larger than
2'x 2'.
iii. Judging Panel will make its recommendations to the EDA by December 15,
2014.
iv. The EDA will review the Judging Panel's recommendations. The EDA may
request a presentation to the EDA from any or all Projects recommended by
the Judging Panel.
v. The EDA makes a recommendation to the City Council by January 20, 2015.
vi. City Council considers and approves Project by January 20,2015.
vii. Participants whose projects were not selected have until 4:00 p.m. on
February 20, 2015 to retrieve their proposals, renderings, mock ups, samples
photographs, drawings, models, renderings or other related proposal
materials from City Hall. The City will dispose of any unclaimed proposal
materials.
viii. Project construction must be completed by June 1, 2015 with an unveiling
celebration projected for July 4,2015.
h. Project submissions are valid for 90 days from the date opened by the EDA.
i. In the event the EDA believes additional clarification of a Project submission is
needed, the EDA will submit a request for clarification to the submitting artist. That
artist has two business days to respond to the EDA in writing.
Section 4: Proposal
The Project mock up, rendering, or sample submittal shall contain only the information requested
below.
Proposal Format
The submittal should follow the Table of Contents listed below:
A. General Information
B. Project Understanding
C. Project Approach
D. Location,Installation and Future Maintenance
E. Additional Information
4
F. Total Project Cost
A brief description of each section follows.
A. General Information
Provide a Project mock up, rendering, or sample that defines the City of Elk River and
"Powered by Nature",which may include photographs or drawings so long as they are no larger
than 24" x 36" or modeled on a base no larger than 2'x 2'.
B. Project Understanding
Submit a one-page letter of interest describing what the City of Elk River and "Powered by
Nature" means to you? The Economic Development Authority is seeking an impactful,
memorable project that communicates this concept.
C. Project Approach
Provide specific approaches, methods, and assumptions that will be utilized to accomplish each
work item as listed in Section 2. Artists may submit as teams. The EDA,in its sole discretion,
may contract with an individual artist or a team.
D. Location, Installation and Future Maintenance
Provide a proposed schedule from project initiation to final completion. The schedule should
include a listing of key tasks within each phase, key milestones and approximate dates, and
deliverables.
E. Additional Information
Include any other information that is believed to be pertinent, but not specifically requested
elsewhere in this RFP.
F. Total Project Cost
The compensation to the selected artist(s) will not exceed $12,000. The Artist(s) shall be
reimbursed between 25-50% of upfront costs for materials and the balance upon satisfactory
completion and installation of the artwork.
The artist shall break out the estimated costs as follows:
a. Public art piece materials
b. Transportation costs
c. Installation costs
d. Future maintenance costs
e. Any other costs or charges deemed relevant by the artist
Section 5: Selection
Process
Members of the Project Judging Panel will evaluate and rank all submitted proposals received by
November 6, 2014. After conclusion of this review, the Panel will recommend the artist and Project
to the EDA. The decision will be based on a combination including, but not limited to: ranking,
presentation of materials, and other qualifications. The EDA will review the recommendations
5
making a recommendation to the City Council. The EDA will make a recommendation to the City
Council. The City Council will make the final selection of the artist and Project. Once authorized to
proceed, the artist will be expected to immediately assist in developing a final scope of services and
contractual agreement.
The City and the EDA reserve the right to waive any irregularity in any submittal or reject any or all
proposals. Neither the City nor the EDA is responsible for any cost incurred by anyone in
preparation for a response to this RFP.
Ranking Criteria
1. Public Art Message—a maximum of 50 points
What does the City of Elk River and "Powered by Nature" mean to you? The Economic
Development Authority is seeking an impactful, memorable Project that communicates this concept
to current and potential residents,businesses, and visitors.
a. Relevance of the piece to the City of Elk River and"Powered by Nature"
2. Memorable and Impactful—a maximum of 20 points
3. Related Understanding—a maximum of 10 points
a. Can the work be built and installed as proposed?
b. Suitability of the artwork for outdoor display, including its maintenance and conservation
requirements
c. Relationship of the artwork to the site and the host community, especially how it serves to
activate or enhance economic development
d. Appropriateness of the scale of the artwork
e. How closely the proposed artwork meets the vision set out in the RFP and the brand
committee guidelines
4. Schedule - a maximum of 10 points
a. Did the applicant meet all the required timelines?
b. How well the proposed schedule from project initiation to final completion (including key
tasks within each phase, key milestones and approximate dates, and deliverables) works for
the City and EDA.
c. Evidence of the artist's ability to work collaboratively and successfully complete the Project
on time and on budget.
5. Cost- a maximum of 10 points
a. What are the City and the EDA's costs in the short and long term?
i. Artists'materials
ii. Transportation costs
iii. Installation costs
6
iv. Future maintenance costs
v. Any other costs or charges
Section 6: Contract Terms and Conditions
Upon selection of an artist(s) and its Project(s), an agreement shall be entered into between the
EDA and the artist(s). It is expected that the agreement will provide for compensation for actual
work completed on a not to exceed basis and include at least the following conditions: Any changes
to the RFP would be communicated to the registered artists.
1. The EDA shall retain ownership of all renderings, mock ups, samples, photographs,
drawing,and the Project prepared pursuant to the selected artist's proposal.
• 2. If for any reason, the artist is unable to fulfill the obligations under the agreement in a
timely and proper manner, the EDA reserves the right to terminate the agreement by
written notice. In this event, the artist shall be entitled to just and equitable
compensation for any satisfactory work completed to that point at the discretion of the
EDA.
3. The artist shall not assign or transfer any interest in the agreement without prior written
consent of the EDA and City.
Registration Due Date/Time
September 8, 2014
4:00 p.m. (CST)
Proposal Due Date/Time
November 6,2014
4:00 p.m. (CST)
Late Submittals will not be considered.
P D M E R E D B Y
NATURE