6.1. SR 08-01-2016
Request for Action
To Item Number
Mayor and City Council 6.1
Agenda Section Meeting Date Prepared by
Presentations, Awards, August 1, 2016Kristin Mroz, Environmental Technician
and Recognitions
Item Description Reviewed by
Climate Smart Municipalities – Germany Tour 2016 Cal Portner, City Administrator
Reviewed by
Action Requested
Presentation on the Climate Smart Municipalities Germany Tour 2016.
Background/Discussion
Cal Portner and Kristin Mroz toured the state of North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany from July 3-10,
2016, as a part of the Climate Smart Municipalities (CSM) partnership. The CSM is a 3-year grant from
the Germany Transatlantic Program, also known as the Marshall Plan. Five Minnesota Cities (Elk River,
Morris, Warren, Duluth, and Rochester) were selected to partner with five North Rhine-Westphalia
communities (Iserlohn, Saerbeck, Arnsberg, Siegen, and Münster) to collaborate on climate and energy
smart projects and programs. The goal of the partnership is to help Minnesota cities achieve the state’s
“Next Generation Energy Act” goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions at least 30% below 2005 levels
by 2025, while boosting the local economy.
A delegation of 27 members representing the five communities, the MN Environmental Quality Board,
the MN Pollution Control Agency, the MN Department of Commerce, the Great Plains Institute, Ever-
Green Energy, Affinity Plus Credit Union, and University of Minnesota traveled to Germany. The
delegation met with German agencies including the Germany Foreign Office, the Federal Ministry for
Economic Affairs and Energy, the North Rhine-Westphalia Ministry for Climate Protection,
Environment, Agriculture, Nature Protection and Consumer Protection, Energieagentur NRW, and the
Federal Environment Agency.
The delegation traveled throughout the state, visiting our partner communities and touring a number of
their sites while also learning from their community leaders. Communities visited included:
Dusseldorf
High Efficiency Combined Heat and Power (CHP) Plant tour
NRW Ministry overview
Roundtable Discussion
Saerbeck (Morris)
Heating Plant tour
Energy Experience Path tour
Energy Management
Bio-Energy Park tour – Compost, Gas to Power, University of Munster Research, Solar,
Wind Turbines
Education for Climate Protection
Citizens Invest – Coop
Storing Renewable Energy
Münster (Rochester)
Transportation Tour
Treaty Room Tour
Zero Energy Student Housing Tour
Community Wind Turbine Tour
Iserlohn (Elk River)
Population: 94,000
Size: 48 miles²
Jobs: manufacturing, metal processing, pharmaceutical and chemical production, waste
management
Two universities
Municipal Utility
Waste-to-Energy Facility (owned by utility)
17 EV Charging Stations on public property
Climate Protection Master Plan (2012)
Awards: NRW CHP Model Municipality, European Energy Award – Gold
Future Goals: Expanding CHP, Electric Mobility, Renewable Energy
CHP Model Community
CHP Incinerator Tour
E-Mobility Tour
Water Treatment Plan CHP Tour
Siegen (Duluth)
Steel Mill Tour
Elk River and Energy City Goals for this partnership are:
From the Energy City 10-year Action Plan:
Explore neighborhood energy systems (micro grid, water collection, etc.)
Explore district heating systems
Achieve 15% above state/federal mandates for renewable energy city-wide by 2024
Advance electric vehicle education and use
Increase recycling and organics recycling
Develop a Climate Action Plan
Financial Impact
None
Attachments
None
ELKRIVER
EN=RGYCITY
r13arrry
G THE 6.
ROWER OF EFFICIENT
C1 *1mate
mar
. 0 u n � c � aI * t *yes
City of
, PBWER1B Bt
Elki��
River �� A
WREI
v
Climate Smart Municipalities
■ Transatlantik-Program (Marshall Plan) Elk River - •
■ 3 year grant, minimum
■ Goals: Morris Saerbeck
■ Reduce greenhouse gas emissions at least
30% below 2005 levels by 2025 Warren Arnsberg
■ Reduce Carbon Footprint
Duluth Siegen
• Assure economic prosperity
■ Comprehensive sustainability practices
Rochester Munster
■ Model different sized
communities/economies
. d
I
Rhelna 61I
Ahaud ,J Hbr{¢r4
Orbypn
rinlre
:YIUf151er Bielefeld I.a04
Wlro"Orr
[3Wfrpn Sennestadl
�mane.rlrh M u fi S r $ P J fJ eY
hacholA Eirnlpartah Phede-
1T"t PUMeirn POO Wled"bruch
i Ahlsn
� ... 4D�qGh Wkg01 Dbr 7er5lrl.-.-' 9gckyrn H .
tVerrie Hamad F�drl?asrl
Din slakes FlesJulft- Lunen upjsladt + N
4"emOrM1Gelsen- hgkjw Kerner)
e4aErC593 kircherkSoolL
H@rtAe Unlsa 4Yerl
QC}i5rt1Ou 3Cr5 DOI'tlfbu nd
IelOgfS Goe hu rn
Duisburg E.SSQf1 witLerl Schwerle k.'4rBtoln
>+k
M ilheim NeI•tiin '-,s4er�nMnl 1Cra�eld Hagen $
buSIdOIi Vel]rerl ;,�,e1,51 Iseilohn
4'Ierscn '+A'-1aPRi;rp�f MescMvr�
MDnejINr,henoth CYOUR& ,">WIr7g�rt Rcrnacheid C'xlrre�eh�� PICTtanterg
l.angeniekl
H64KWr4 Grmnt5-bloh [? ;.p i•. 10tlry grg$U;r96 .��ti
LffY�RLICUSgOfF
Cin 68rghairn X611 bac
Nt- Qlppki
Uliikh Hans" ILrhliut
.!' EschwMMr Kerp" Frfi~
{ Sl"burg
Aoeh@n Nniim Erhoudt MIMI-l
Bonn
;i
Euskinclrbn '4�elbl�.
Name First Name Postion C)rganisation
1 Seufl ert W11i Exec. Director MN Env ronmenta'I Qua `ty Board
Delegation 2 Linc Stine John Commissioner[ .°{irister' [-.-IN Fc ution Contra Agency
3 Director of Government IAN Dept. of Commerce
GrceLner .Alison A"a`rs
4 sen cr p anner;co-director Great Plains Institute
Finis Abby GreenStep Cities program
Smith Julie GUEST
E Smith Ken President and CECT Ever-Green Energy
Volkmann Brian 'h of Financial Officer Affinity Plus Federa Credit Union
S Properties and Facilities City of Duluth
Birkeland Erik Mana.Der
9 Jackson Alex Energy Coordinator City of Du lush
10 director, Pub',c Works & C'tyr of Du uth
Benning Jim Utilities
11 Simonson Erik legislator MN House of Representatives
12 Mraz Kristin Environmenta -eche c an City of Elk River
13 Partner Calvin City Administrator City ofElk River
14 Hill Blaine City Administrator City of Morris
15 Herrmann Bryan Vice C:hanceJJor University of Minnesota
16 Baker Mitzi Director Rcchester,101msted Planning
17 Kotschel;ar r-lark Genera Manager Rochester Public Utilities
18 Norton K n legislator MN House of Representatives
19 City AdministratcrlC'erk City of%Varren
Mortenson Shannon Treasurer
20 McMillan Brent City of Warren
21 .Stumpf Caro [°; deographerj
22 Stumpf LeRoy e; s atcr MN Senate
23 sc ent st° Renewable University of Minnesota
Energy, W est Centra I
Buchanan Eric Research and Outreach
24 Program Director, University of Minnesota
International Energy Policy
&Cooperation, Insitute an
Engel Sabine the Environment
75 Managing Director and University of Minnesota
Gilbert Lewis CFCs, Institute on the
26 Exec. Director, Natural University of Minnesota
eberg Ralf Res.aurces Research
27 Humphrey Schaal far Public University of Minnesota
Wilson Elizabeth lAffairs
•
German Partners
nister1orn 10r Kliimastbutz. U mwe It.
Landwrirtsckraft, Natury and Verbraucherschutz
des Landes Nordrhein-Westfalen
■ Germany's Foreign Office
■ Germany's Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy
■ North Rhine-Westphalia Ministry for Climate Protection, Environment,
Agriculture, Nature Protection and Consumer Protection (KULN�
■ Energieagentur.NRW
■ Federal Environment Agency (UBA)
6 a
fks.
Iserlohn '
■ Population: 94,000
■ Size: 48 miles2
■ Jobs: manufacturing, metal processing, pharmaceutical and chemical production,
waste management
■ Two universities
i�lunicip al Utility
■ Waste-to-Energy Facility (owned by utility)
■ 17 EV Charging Stations on public property
■ Climate Protection Master Plan (2012)
■ Awards: NRW CHP Model Municipality, European Energy Award — Gold
0 Future Goals: Expanding CHP, Electric Mobility, Renewable Energy
,
� , 2
Iserlohn
m . v
CHP Model Community
0 CHP Incinerator Tour
0 E-Mobility Tour
0 W3{Cƒ Treatment Plant CHP
Tout
-
� � � ��^ �
i
l
'+ SauerlandMobil
----.� ELEKTRISCH
EMISSIONSFREI
k�
GERAUSCHARM
1 ate..
i -
v
Dusseldorf
■ High Efficiency CHP Plant tour
■ NRW i —iistry overview
■ Roundtable
I.
1+
'Ao
t
•'�� .� Com. i�. �. - • q, a, *' �N f����Kwy,J is y�f Y.. � `r.. a, x • .. , N.• ' _��'•
lift
37
7-0
t"�I '• f.�,f k - .. •�5� is +�• �\!=, * ^� � ' �� �-
'�� ~ 'saw_. �` �`.'" 1• �. r .: �,� �y' s- .
r- f{� G;l L• 5 r,, v .�t ! , �Tti -�f
..,,,�c Fes.... �i. �.��,. r a•'jR i'
may�7//y , -�• '�,�
Saerbeck
■ Heating Plant tour
■ Energy Experience Path tour
■ Energy Management
■ Bio-Energy Park tour — Compost, Power to Gas, University of Munster
Research, Solar, Wind Turbines
■ Education for Climate Protection _ f
■ Citizens Invest — Coop
■ Storing Renewable Energy
Energy Plant
and District
Heating
of
wo
VIE!"
MOM
•�S t,n��k
��
- or I
a
ON
.�,, � ,�. � �c•ice` ��
s _
lAA
.. ,.
�t
dw
IL
Fr
o3f-
-�' �_.:
._<,. _ . e
h9 x t
".� .I
fR
F
` 1`
f
i. � _ t .J,
a i1
.. � � � G o
' � .. .—
a.� ,._,.,r .._�-__ _. _
— - - �+e� _ _— i s—.
4' +�'' _
� 1. � .
� �
f
I tV
I
� } .:,+� �•_,. •,.�+�. �. "•�' t � _ •:ter' .,--,-- -
IVA
All
n+G ;. y %4:y, �''. " - ,art•,i .�� Vlo, '
7 - Av,
. II�
a:.
y
M u n ste r
■ Transportation Tour
■ Peace Room Tour �
■ Ener Efficient Student Housing Tour 1 � '
Energy g
■ Community Wind Turbine Tour ►
, l
__
jt
i
i
CO,
v y�
N 1
F �.0 �� ���' � r ^G' • � .�•,mac. ¢¢ a� + .., _ } , �.
rY�r*� ti
ask .
II
i
IIII_ _ �' • � t�°„/ I
- �
a
i
l -
� r
•
_ 1• �,n
d
F
a5:
•
German Energy Transformation
(Energiewende)
WHY GERMANS
A r ,• • ' THE r 1
■ Phase-out Nuclear by 2022 92% of Germ:an consumers agree energy tr- •
■ Decrease Greenhouse
Gasses/Coal
■ Energy Independence Reduction of
Nuclear power z carbon dioxide
■ Renewable Investments phase-out emissions
92 %
Agreement
Shortage of
Fossil Fuel
Otherreasons
` resources
Disagreement
9
, l 1
rERIVER
=RGYCITY
Where We Are
�EM�NSTPAT'N aEtNEVqAi3k"�
G THE POWER OF EFFICIEN-f &
■ City-wide GHG assessment
■ City operations GHG assessment
■ City Fleet average 9 mpg
■ Northstar Commuter rail
■ 100% city building and residential waste incinerated
■ 17% renewable energy generation city-wide
9
. i
ELKRIVER
E - RGYCIIST`
Future Goals
oEM�NSrPanry aENEA��E
G THE POWER OF EFFICIEN-f &
■ Energy City 10-year Action Plan
■ Explore neighborhood energy systems (micro grid, water collection, etc.)
■ Explore district heating systems
■ Achieve 15% above State/Federal mandates for renewable energy city-wide
by 2024
■ Electric vehicle education and use
■ Increase recycling and organics recycling
■ Climate Action Plan