Loading...
6.3 ERMUSR 02-13-2018 Elk River Municipal Utilities UTILITIES COMMISSION MEETING TO: FROM: ERMU Commission Tom Sagstetter—Conservation and Key Accounts Manager MEETING DATE: AGENDA ITEM NUMBER: February 13, 2018 6.3 SUBJECT: Electric Vehicle Suitability Assessment Presentation ACTION REQUESTED: None BACKGROUND: In 2017, ERMU received a grant from the American Public Power Association. As part of the grant, ERMU was to work with the City of Elk River to do an Electric Vehicle Assessment Study. This study was conducted by FleetCarma. The study period was from March 2017 through November 2017. The study evaluated 20 vehicles including 8 from the Utilities and 12 from the city fleet. The results were presented in December to both City of Elk River and ERMU staff. DISCUSSION: Staff will present the Electric Vehicle Suitability Assessment presentation. FINANCIAL IMPACT: N/A ATTACHMENTS: • Electric Vehicle Suitability Assessment Presentation Page 1 of 1 165 = U- as V) 400 .M CO lea MIMI i a 0 Elm E co as y in. a) L u) n3MEI EMI CD 1411 oil W. 2 CI3 H OP 0 mom CA ag iiiiiE imal W • v 0 W E as U C. ru N •— CU O y= a ►S 0 O 0 06 0- c = .- N 0 .�..� 'E cm '0 E ©O U I >>, C = +•, w_ > CQ C/) COCL. U IP C.) V C.) (/) _� C.) cii CUCly O = -i c — = C/) CQ o T.) a) a' = E t- = E O a c cn E C.) —w YO C..) E v y— O y' tan C U — 0 0 CI. CO .4.-i 0 >, P% =ca� - AO ID' a .- .— as C au 2 cn .r-: to cu Cn = CQ CQ a •!-_ = .(/) C O a To N •— O • .— E +.+ a. •� o o C v +, •) II 4—a (7et as .N = a > a� CZ H H LL .F a) in W !'I MO E O LTJ N C..) CO i G1 UA 1+_ jCD 0 a 3 = 0 CL O E - ..„:0. c▪a▪ .� � VI 1o cn 0) CL 0 E a) `U +., O IV . 4- -0 = E >+ CO G) E �_ �'y CO .>, _= CB C) J 0 \,,, .._, . = Ca a) > Va) c��a = 3 E O UA aH •0 c1')q .� CO a) .N c E) nA' o 1 , Qco :2 1 �Ca - i 4--+V N �.4.0 co - it'icanO N a' t:',,,,,* ' '',.‘ '� •0 CZ V U) I) V a) = 0.. Q .)cn 4-1 >, o a- im O E 0E ._ — , c) = '0 t '''4 2 ZS CI 0 2 i O. c'i CC = y-mW !I n3 S E a) = a) O sm. ax CL 4-1 0 a 2 fit = as a) , ,u C N V ca E CU - CD te= > A T.) '> 'OD �= k i isil ° (/) ' : ' 1 '1,19• 1 .= Oa) • 4 W .5 O IP •p ca .= N N = , \ L'F x co 'D o .= 'I a • I O 0 co 0 -0 a. bA _ I. VQ O O •+ _ N + \� CONom i ._ \ 0 ' (i) N 1 ell ..i O .4-' Zcn a) C__ — O .v C = a) O cu � > t, f - ‘04 C. • MEN t CD y.• a) II a) 41) V = gCUW W s !I ra 111010r E (0 U -i-J cu cu _ 4—... Lo ..... . E CI) '7) 5 E E al u 1E 4...c Nifigirl) rz: ,,,, .... 2 2 › 0 - .....w go ,- . I c — c p 5. ,--- m c s N .ti k CD ... 4 U) CD ‘eil MI I ism U. CZ lil i Ill $ oil ci a •P •,- o ,.., C = T., in 0 k- la CD Ni a, R C.) cu L.6 2 v co _ Cl) ___ ..... , 0 .. = rill... SU ti iit' 10 _ 4..1 CA til F•4 rIIIIIIIII. V "' rj il, o Ca 61 ,.. . C E.' rn Ti .— cu = = E T 2, -to CD w ilia > E ---' •,..D > (i) 0 P c _ U) ma CD U) U) II<IC -Ffi- 74 w u ,41 c., z v w 0 — u ,._ c R, 2 Ti. •— IUIIII -......„ c C ra ....„ •W = z-, E ".r (f) N ,, , E — cu 1.1.1 0) 0.,.) "10 ts, s mr 3 CD LL m 1.1) CD •...... NIW — —_„ Lil ri,' 11, 1.1111111 aliiii = 03 .... E co cl. .c 0 C.) c = = a) E CCI a.. inlia CD 4:1.) ..Y U. uJ (13 dl0 •2 jfd t 000. + E • • o -; : • 00 T: /h E 2 pro .0 0 0 6 L E 12 4.0.t4 I o g • I 40 CD i; -0 E > o.1 gt tt V :4 3 9 M E I CA 3 ,13 I :1. c tg • 17. CL) p, E Cl) C▪ O (s) • § 4:t MINIM 1 'r 41.0 .?8 MOM raim 114:2 MINo 1-0 •IMO 4 •min MEM MC 1 I •E g CLI 1'7▪ 0 z 9/ t. 1.1.11 00 0/ po 0 9, lflg Ca) 'CI; o c o bo co ,L0 C 111111111111 — MUM i 0 I 0 k9 ••• r CO ,4801 ti) E 4 ._ • 0 • CD 0 CZ CO LLI O U U a 11111japli , fri L.... CO o v CU Wm Y. : O O v ?G1.NP5ti�ap1Z O V W m X61°3... - 'a N ,9�Fe9 > 2 co ed m 0 6_ U Fc'K,,s0GG O R d "E. w 2Gl`Ng58Ka19j... 2 Q ▪ N In ZG... 3GN2E H R m w w - U 1- 't .r.--- - -- 7p8Gc28K5s'''''" �,. w W. v 7 = O U 0 0 10 iXZ066°P 3 w 2" D L 1fi5*Z15,a�P V, U o O ,B' 101*2g6gGEC,. t. 40 N yT., _ W v O O - �,651`',P OF,,`P b0 d a w v v N 7 f W 2. b0 da O 'G ZN5f13... CL O Z = 2 h r 4.11NKJ4EosI G}Z... W n .- ILL1G ▪CI) — w cn ,0RF�ava�Kc..%0""4\ . w N N m -J, , H U) •— g6645. a 'C ' w ‘i M ■ � 1 i, ,. _-- .,.,,issl.'6''°' l� W O - _ 11 4, 6p0.t... b0 C Mil. 5K6 G� i T te CO) a+ 60• O E m a v ciCZ ^ ik., KBaGGp..• 1 j4NSg _v N) CD V � y Vn1M 4i BNZF N <- •� , III t... ....„ 5K9PRDEGG /D aim QPM ° - a — C ZFPt1? N5gx1 C.) Um IIIIIIMIIIII L m mm m N a N O (iw)a uvsip ie;oi Zo NW E 4 v N N o o L 42) UW u _ z11 N Qa Ctl Z. H N Y al cen C �¢ D W _...dr,111111101 n3n3 (13U 1 1 1 1 W^, 1 1 1 CD 1 1 I I S 0 1. 1 ._ Qi,3 i i I 1 i i , 1 i '2cl, I I I I I I I y I I I I `i, ® Io I I I I I I V I gra. c I s , 1 N I I I I I I I - . I 1 1 7 r 3+1. 41 T! ! II.I I I ,, ! .1 I I I v .. I I I 1 i ! .co _ 4.9 1 CO M 2 A 2 4 2 .0 —6 .' P P C.) Q ID — :alta P AQPN CO C EE u H o w 0 ON N o a W '4' CD I U. :14 N RS 0 06 _ � o CO Cr) CD .O = = UJ cQ ca 03 -= 00 }+ �_ 4-,N `n u) c N W CtS }+ a) � c) � = = a o m o a) .,a n °- .v _ a c_ = MEM CI)oc GN) >, G) 'OA 0 co E rn E 4mil CD LCL 03 moo 1,1 R3 Nov (r, E L roV cu arcu 0f rs RD - - +e L 0 CO 2 C sJ to et �o a C- -- o 4 oz o Y co V. - - v 1 0 LI Li.) ca mat 3}G allow asJad E N N N N Q 41 S. - CC o o CO CO ._ O c-1 r-1 > = a) a) +-1 10.0 _' CCS CO •_ '1 = 4-'-+ 04:1) C CA Co) = ai O c O C13 CCI i .a - a) N a--+ a) 4 � 0 a -C C. a) 'o cn COU) CU a� as Cl) O N i 9- p V > am G p a) O O L 1E = :' C ( 1 > > 2 >' o p > U 1.- = . -C O ,p 0 -C Na) > i +=+ 0 NO G) = a- EU O N V CO + 4.+ a;� U ) ii etS CU a S > a) > c 8 ,_ T. p a) a) •LMNV G) iv .01ca > tea) O s= + � a-+ , c� te •_ co _ Ci E CU 0 .O CZ O ' = ca = p > CCG L c '42 'a V .> ca LL ca -a 42) N as C � MT • CO s M a �+ aD CL) N a -0 O V 4-1 'i No O ' YV >beaU � ci Q- o Q • . cn0H ca cn u) E > . o_ Y W SOO FA1 a3 NOY E (13 (..) 4-, cu (a) Li- ii +8' cti c 0 Vi 0 't ig Z ID IS ''.6 W 446 a r — C 7. 0 2 cu IC m N- 6. u 13 0 ,, a a3 !v s VI a. 0 VI E v., ci• u ,0 -. u th zr, , - co SZ. E 4-, .... = as a) 4.. ... E cp (C5 . E No 0, 1 in C (0) a....s. < 0 ,,si:) Cy) a- Z" MUM O's 44"4 00 _ = 4) • Z.; iliel al U 4 Cti Z C awl" mC 0 LO t 13 0 ....... — =4.4 C 01 Nal, CO C 004. D ..... v) co) .... ' Nt„171 ct N 4D •.,,.. c 0.. ..._ ci) 0) —LL ilia E .......) = ......) .... •W L1.3 LL 0 MN CO tn 0. 120 C) = •mi. > co '2 cn ,.. cu 0 .... C.) 1--. ...v ail Id FI (6NOV EV Q) a) cu a) 4- ._c▪o v N 'i +-+ Cn VI C91 €7) 1 a) C13 c co cp > a--+ co E = 'x O 2 >, Q i O_ O co 1 NI onO as = 40 O >, s= vi a'cr.) cn a- — NOWA > C a.) a E a) irto ON N c co) a.' Iii Q ca E 1::::1 ro 0 L.) VI O 4.70 12, Lu -a z o a) -0 • C = ca CI •LL E a M = 0 N � ' .= a ~ ;� C13 5 E Zr) 4071 o = W s !I n3 E U a? aJ I L7'4 A L� ' fig —guy c' LA Sys 'tl!,, y �r4 r 1 L 1 r O e� n l I ' - LJ`I f�`9 1 0 i8Y 4JS iii +jy irf i.l? yr} IA- co as IP f. vin c- O O ' , LU LU 40 LU w w w 4-1C .0_ cE Qu uuu ' I. z z - O U e = a)) 14 "@ •— 7") 4.11 4. u 10 a.) E J41) > E G� E a ) •1'4 sz2 i u) V 4 0 co) _ O Q V � c Zi CL f '! 0 kei CO 0. u. u. ca a' I) CLI au CA �o 4.0 o 0 ,,,� , o — , s= L (L) I -0 47, C.) vi a' = ca �,41 C21 co '1101110 ca •— efi LLMEI y St CD WINV CCI W E .iiip,001F1 ni (13u N oe orf C O .- i W E — o 2a) G) 4p .041LC) co _i ,..'4 , =i�h ) L ^ CI3 ) rAt CD U .> i a) N 000 a) O .F+ UA N = a) � E { -CS N N- _ O N M c C a Ln .�+' r) .� ti = •- o EI .... i: , .t-I t...41.0 O :111. .O O = H > _ U.0 O U) f+ _ = bA = �_N f l co H E 8 _ . H ._ cft Co F. CN Tu al/ 000 C � 0 .. ICt0 ' o ti .y .. .� N = Z .a .-' CO CO.) .E � N E ._ CL) iimi E co ni,) . , J 5 H E $ ti N C.) CG 4R� `u) Ia' Y E- W dl a n3 U N a) a 4" 0 _Q oso c co 'ti 1 Lfl N m rr. a c . , • rn r- um E E t.r, cB 0 i v i N_ CL 'N CU -a a 4-0 CO .t= V '' 12 'P '2 ''t4 '2 'T - 7:3 � 0 R = G C = = = = = ._ a) 0 0 0 0 0 o E c C 0 N 0 E a� 0 a)) a) ap •— C) :a (Na > a) ci. cu cu ,c .� E co o r sLary y a) cu IA 1.4 -5 N k-O. i 1 4-4 2, ( .) F-- 0 a) Q cts I -- - o al a :4-1E CL > ca CO N 2 a. '" 0 Nct) 0 ...= 4.1 a) .oCU 0 _0 Tel co CL a I- N '_ E = 0 E V a, N ke W � L (13 NO. Q] I" CU CU Q) 0 %ice = } = O O A C C.) CDa)N .40 { - N � N .0 O a..+ C.) CO 1111 U ... M 0 oo U -+ 13.13 a co N CO = O O Qa +a 00 to Q0 j{': U) o Q C Q. O — C) ca E ..f=1 O . o = Cl) Els C.) 40) CM CL O N O N C a. ate+ j . U C� t CD 0 Q) 1 4t M (,) N411) ._ ;40 _ O CO) • J 1%- W' la W ill (13 poor 41 8 . ..... Ho v •— O - i to p p O. p bA y . — 'r. c3 O 00 CO 0. .r 0 O = N W `.- V v M T. c.) _ _ > _ CO 1` k■■I •— CD ._ a) 0 0 17; .° .= -8 >, d'A° z E , c4 cu a 11) 0 Cfi 4) 171 E +a Cm12 ccs.�,r v — ' E > H U) U) .y v c. a3 2 u O O p a _ t/) i a) _ '� O y— C v O _ �+ p 00 a .— — _ co _OOt > = M a) Ki m . 'I = a COca CD CD — = >, E — p a) O co 1 a) . O s.. am 142 O = •F.+ N © b10 = v 0 '0 47. v Ob N ti N tO = o CD W .y a O '9 - O Z . . • . a) • C� i Cl) '. 00 CD m e-I W I I I az O N • W