Loading...
7.1. EDSR 03-16-2020Request for Action To Item Number Economic Development Authority 7.1 Agenda Section Meeting Date Prepared by General Business March 16, 2020 Colleen Eddy, Economic Development Specialist Item Description Reviewed by Public Art Initiative Amanda Othoudt, ED Director Reviewed by Cal Portner, City Administrator Action Requested Approve, by motion, a recommendation from the Public Art Subcommittee to terminate this round of applications, amend and reissue a new RFP. Background/Discussion At their July 15, 2019, meeting, the EDA approved the RFP for a public art installation. The RFP was posted and delivered to a master list of artists in and around the Central MN Arts District. Two proposals were received. The public art location, in front of Granite Shores, was identified which is the same place the soup ladle was located. The property owner agreed to the location, however, is requiring engineered plans as the it sits above the underground parking lot. At their February 18, 2020, subcommittee meeting, the finalist presented their proposal, however, the subcommittee was not comfortable moving forward with the project due to concerns with the lack of engineering plans and variations in the artists dimensions. The subcommittee recommended the EDA take no action and table the discussion until the plans are complete. Later that evening, the EDA tabled the discussion until March 16 to allow the artist time to update engineering plans. The artist has since retracted his proposal and would like to resubmit something completely different. At their March 10, 2020, meeting, the subcommittee met to discuss the next steps following the retraction of the artist’s proposal and made the following recommendations: 1. To terminate this round of applications and start a new RFP process. 2. To amend the RFP and consider the following changes: a) Eliminate the 100-mile radius criteria b) Eliminate the “What does Elk River mean to you” and further defining this question in the RFP. c) Granite Shores has been identified as the primary location, further identify the parameters for this location, and identify two additional locations for the artist to consider. d) The Public Art Subcommittee will identify a theme for public art which will revolve around Energy City, Powered by Nature or the history of transportation in Elk River. The Elk River Vision A welcoming community with revolutionary and spirited resourcefulness, exceptional service, and community engagement that encourages and inspires prosperity e) The EDA consider submitting the RFP to all 11 art councils and expand the reach. f) Redefine the scoring Financial Impact The EDA budgeted $5,000 in 2020 as a matching grant for a public art installation at their June 17, 2019, meeting. Attachments  Public Art Sub-Committee Packet (March 10, 2020)  Central MN Arts Board 2021 Grants Calendar Meeting of the EDA Public Art Subcommittee AGENDA Tuesday, March 10, 2020 3:30 pm Elk River City Hall Upper Town Conference Room 1. CALL MEETING TO ORDER 2. CONSIDER AGENDA 3. CONSENT AGENDA Considered to be routine and noncontroversial by the City Council and will be approved by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a Councilmember, staff member, or citizen so requests, in which case the item will be removed from the consent agenda and considered under the regular agenda. 3.1 February 18, 2020, Meeting Minutes 4. GENERAL BUSINESS 4.1 Public Art Proposal Update 5. ANNOUCEMENTS 6. ADJOURNMENT This agenda is available in alternate formats upon a 72 hour advanced notice. Auxiliary aids and services are also available upon a 72 hour advanced notice. Please contact the City Clerk at 763. 635.1000 to make a request. Examples of alternate formats may include: large print, Braille, audio tape, etc. Examples of auxiliary aids may include a sign language interpreter, assistive listening device, etc. Meeting Protocol No sidebar discussions No interruptions State your concern Ensure you understand Don’t take things personally Adhere to time limits Come prepared Ensure all are heard Meeting of the Elk River Economic Development Authority Public Art Sub-committee Held at the Elk River City Hall Tuesday, February 18, 2020 Members Present: Dan Tveite, Sharon Tracy (5:05 p.m.), Mike Niziolek, Ann McCormick Members Absent: Jennifer Wagner Staff Present: Economic Development Director, Amanda Othoudt and Economic Development Specialist, Colleen Eddy Others Present: Matthew Coppersmith, Coppersmith Customs 1. Call Meeting to Order Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, the meeting of the Elk River Economic Development Authority Public Art Sub-Committee was called to order at 5:00 p.m. by Dan Tveite. 2. Consider Agenda Moved by Michael Niziolek and seconded by Ann McCormick to approve the agenda. Motion carried 4-0. 3. Consent Agenda 3.1 February 6, 2020, Meeting Minutes Moved by Michael Niziolek and seconded by Ann McCormick to approve the consent agenda. Motion carried 4-0. 4. General Business 4.1 Public Art Proposals Ms. Othoudt presented the staff report. Matthew Coppersmith, of Coppersmith Customs presented his revised art piece. Scale is 2” = 1’ with the final art being 10’ – 12’. Members discussed their concerns with the project; the low piece representing the river should be shorten so nobody hits their head, what engineering is needed as there is an underground garage under the proposed area, thickness of the steel strong enough as it will rust through time, the size of the base is proposed to be 2’ x 36” and will be bolted to the ground. After discussion the committee felt that they needed more information and engineered drawings addressing their concerns before they could recommend approval to the EDA. 5. Announcements No announcements 6. Adjournment There being no further business, Dan Tveite adjourned the meeting of the Elk River Economic Development Authority at 5:30 p.m. Minutes prepared by Amanda Othoudt. Dan Tveite, EDA President Tina Allard, City Clerk The Elk River Vision A welcoming community with revolutionary and spirited resourcefulness, exceptional service, and community engagement that encourages and inspires prosperity Request for Action To Public Art Subcommittee Item Number 4.1 Agenda Section General Business Meeting Date March 10, 2020 Prepared by Amanda Othoudt, ED Director Item Description Public Art Proposal Reviewed by Cal Portner, City Administrator Reviewed by Action Requested Provide a recommendation to the EDA for a public art proposal. Background/Discussion At the Public Art Subcommittee’s February 18, 2020, meeting, Matthew Coppersmith of Coppersmith Customs presented his final public art mockup to the committee. The art location, in front of Granite Shores, was identified which is the same place the soup ladle was located. The property owner agreed to the location, however, is requiring engineered plans as the location sits above the underground parking lot. The Subcommittee was not comfortable moving forward with the project due to concerns with the lack of engineering plans and variations in the artists dimensions. They recommended to table the discussion until the plans are complete. After conversations with the artist, he retracted his proposal and would like to resubmit something completely different. Staff is requesting that the subcommittee provide a recommendation to the EDA on whether they would like to resubmit the Public Art RFP and call for artists. The next deadline for a grant submittal has not been released yet but will likely be in August. Financial Impact The EDA budgeted $5,000 in 2020 as a matching grant for a public art installation at their June 17, 2019, meeting. Attachments  Public Art RFP 1 Request for Proposal Public Art Installation City of Elk River, MN Registration Due Date/Time October 4, 2019 4:00 p.m. (CST) Proposal Due Date/Time December 6, 2019 4:00 p.m. (CST) City of Elk River & Economic Development Authority 13065 Orono Parkway Elk River, MN 55330 2 Request for Proposal Public Art Installation City of Elk River, MN Section 1 General Information This document solicits Requests for Proposal (RFP) for a public art installation for the City of Elk River, Minnesota. RFP Administration Address all correspondence, requests for additional information, registration, and proposal submissions to: Amanda Othoudt Economic Development Director City of Elk River 13065 Orono Parkway Elk River, MN 55330 aothoudt@ElkRiverMN.gov 763.635.1042 Deadlines Registrations will be accepted until 4:00 p.m. on October 4, 2019 Proposals from registered artists will be accepted until 4:00 p.m. on December 6, 2019 Acceptance of Proposal Contents The contents of this RFP will be included in the contract between the selected artist and the EDA. All information in the proposal is subject to disclosure under the provisions of Minnesota Statutes Chapter 13 – Minnesota Government Data Practices Act. Section 2 Background On May 5, 2014, members of the Elk River arts community, city staff, and the Parks and Recreation Master Plan Planning Team met to review opportunities and potential locations and partnerships for public art in the city. Participants also identified goals, strategies, and themes for the public art plan. Members of the Elk River Arts Alliance, the Regional Arts Council, the Minnesota State Arts Board, the Central Minnesota Arts Board, Independent School District 728, the Elk River Economic Development Authority, and various theaters and other performance groups were all in attendance. Attendees viewed a presentation and participated in discussions of public art opportunities and best practices as they applied to Elk River. They then defined the potential scope, goals, opportunities and approach to public art in the community. The input gathered at this meeting formed the vision for the Elk River Public Art Plan. Section 3 Overall Scope of Services What does the City of Elk River mean to you? The EDA is seeking an impactful, memorable project that communicates this vision to current and potential residents, businesses, and visitors. 3 1. Participatory Process Artists located within 100 miles of Elk River are asked to develop a mock up, rendering, or sample of a public art installation (project) as an entry as an RFP. Entries may include photographs, drawings or renderings no larger than 24” x 36” or modeled on a base no larger than 2’ x 2’. Entries must include two and three dimensional renderings: 1,800 pixels wide in one PDF and include title, description and dimension. 2. Background The Elk River Public Arts Plan states two elements must be discussed and defined in the proposal. One is the role of public art. The other is the role and management of the program to support public art. The plan concluded that successful public art meets the following characteristics. a. It is accessible to the public (location and financially) b. Has context specific to the site or community c. Includes community involvement d. Can express community values, enhance the environment, transform a landscape, heighten awareness, or question assumptions 3. Locations and Maintenance Artists will be required to analyze and suggest the best possible location(s) for the project with the goal to enhance tourism and economic vitality, and consider future maintenance needs and costs. 4. Vision & Overview Project submissions must promote the role of public art in the following ways: Accessible to the public (location and financially), have context specific to the site or the community, include community involvement, express community values, enhance the environment and landscape, and heighten awareness or question assumptions. a. Innovation – Create a project that defines the city, its businesses, residents, and tourists. b. Economic Development – Create a project that enhances the city’s economic base and tourism. c. Judging – The panel of judges will choose a winner to complete their project. The panel will include a representative from the City Council, EDA, Parks and Recreation Commission and a resident at-large. d. Purchase of Project – The selected artist will be compensated for their project, which shall cover design, installation, transportation and materials costs and an honorarium to the selected artist. e. Location of Project – Project submissions must recommend a location on city property to install the project in accordance with the Elk River Public Arts Plan. City property includes but is not limited to: a. Locations identified should be places where public art displays would likely be most engaged and should be highly trafficked areas. b. The Elk River Public Arts Plan describes a variety of art mediums and locations such as downtown, community gateways, city hall, community parks, neighborhood parks, and trail corridors. f. Future Maintenance – Define future maintenance costs to keep the project attractive and safe. Project maintenance and associated maintenance costs will be further defined in a meeting with the Artist. 4 5. RFP Timeline: a. Registration. All participants must register their interest in submitting a proposal by October 4, 2019. Registration is mandatory and a prerequisite to submitting a proposal. b. Proposals, renderings, mock ups, or samples are due by December 6, 2019. c. Proposals will be presented to the judging panel in January and may include photographs, drawings, or renderings no larger than 24” x 36”, or modeled on a base no larger than 2’ x 2’. d. Judging panel will make its recommendations to the EDA by February 2020. e. The EDA will review the judging panel’s recommendations. The EDA may request a presentation to the EDA from any or all projects recommended by the judging panel. f. The EDA makes a recommendation to the City Council by February 17, 2020. g. City Council chooses final project for submission to the Central MN Arts Board grant by February 17, 2020. h. Participants whose projects were not selected have until 4:00 p.m. on February 21, 2020 to retrieve their proposals, renderings, mock ups, samples photographs, drawings, models, renderings or other related proposal materials from City Hall. The city will dispose of any unclaimed proposal materials. i. The city will submit an application for review to the Central MN Arts Board by March 25, 2020. j. The city will submit a formal grant application on April 8, 2020. k. The Central MN Arts Board reviews all grant applications on May 14, 2020. l. In June 2020, the City Council will decide whether to move forward with the proposed project considering available funding sources. m. Project construction must begin by July 30, 2020. n. Project construction must be completed by September, 2020 with an unveiling celebration projected for October, 2020. 6. Project submissions are valid for 90 days from the date opened by the EDA. 7. In the event the EDA believes additional clarification regarding a Project submission or additional information is needed, the EDA will submit a request for clarification to the submitting artist. That artist has two business days to respond to the EDA in writing. Section 4 Proposal The project mock up, rendering, or sample submittal shall contain only the following information. Proposal Format The submittal should follow the Table of Contents listed below: A. General Information B. Artistic Merit/Quality C. Project Understanding D. Project Approach E. Location, Installation and Future Maintenance F. Additional Information G. Total Project Cost 5 A. General Information Provide a project mock up, rendering, or sample that defines the City of Elk River which may include photographs or drawings so long as they are no larger than 24” x 36” or modeled on a base no larger than 2’ x 2’. Entries must include two & three dimensional renderings: 1800 pixels wide in one PDF and include title, description and dimension. Each artist must include a current resume. B. Artistic Merit/Quality a. Provide an explanation of how this project will enhance artistic, cultural, and educational values of the viewers of this piece of art. b. Provide an explanation of how this project will advance the artist’s goals relating to public art and build upon past public art involvement. c. Provide an explanation of how the artist’s entry will allow all community members a greater understanding and awareness of art. d. Provide an explanation of how the public survey influenced your choice of project submittal. e. How will your project create a broader understanding and appreciation of your chosen medium? C. Project Understanding Submit a one-page letter of interest describing “What the City of Elk River means to you?” The EDA is seeking an impactful, memorable project that communicates this concept. D. Project Approach Provide specific approaches, methods, and assumptions that will be utilized to accomplish each work item as listed in Section 3, Part 2. Artists may submit as teams. The EDA, in its sole discretion, may contract with an individual artist or a team. E. Location, Installation and Future Maintenance Provide a proposed schedule from project initiation to final completion. The schedule should include a listing of key tasks within each phase, key milestones and approximate dates, and deliverables. F. Additional Information Include any other information that is believed to be pertinent, but not specifically requested elsewhere in this RFP. G. Total Project Cost The compensation to the selected artist(s) will not exceed $20,000. The artist shall be reimbursed between 25-50% of upfront costs for materials and the balance upon satisfactory completion and installation of the artwork. The artist shall break out the estimated costs as follows: a. Public art piece materials b. Transportation costs c. Installation costs d. Future maintenance costs e. Any other costs or charges deemed relevant by the artist 6 Section 5 Selection Process Members of the Project Judging Panel will evaluate and rank all submitted proposals received by December 6, 2019, after conclusion of this review, the panel will recommend the artist and project to the EDA. The decision will be based on a combination including, but not limited to: ranking, presentation of materials, and other qualifications. The EDA will review the recommendations making a recommendation to the City Council. The City Council will make the final selection of the artist and project to be submitted for grant funding. After determination of grant funding by the Central MN Arts Board, the city will consider whether to move forward with the project considering available funding sources. The artist will be expected to assist in developing a final scope of services and contractual agreement prior to commencing the project. Disclosure and Disclaimer The city and the EDA reserve the right to waive any irregularity or defect in any submittal or reject any or all proposals. Receipt of responses to this RFP does not obligate the city or EDA to hire any respondent. Neither the city nor the EDA is responsible for any cost incurred by anyone in preparation for a response to this RFP including but not limited to costs associated with preparing a proposal or participating any presentations related to this RFP. The city and the EDA reserve the right to modify and/or suspend any and all aspects of this RFP at any time by providing notice to responding parties. The city anticipates applying for a grant from the Central MN Arts Board to finance all or a portion of a proposed project. In the event that the city does not receive the grant funding, the city reserves the right to continue to move forward with the project using other funding sources or to decide that the proposed project is not feasible at any time in its sole discretion. This RFP is for informational purposes only. Any action taken by the city and EDA in response to proposals made pursuant to this RFP, or in making any award or failing or refusing to make any award, shall be without liability or obligation on the part of the city or EDA or any of their officers, employees or advisors. This RFP is being provided by the city and the EDA without any warranty or representation, expressed or implied, as to its content, accuracy or completeness. Any reliance on the information contained in this RFP, or on any communications with the city’s officials, employees or advisors, shall be at the responder’s own risk. This RFP is made subject to correction of errors, omissions, or withdrawal without notice. This RFP does not constitute an offer by the city or the EDA. The city’s and the EDA’s determination as to the qualifications and acceptability of any party or parties submitting a response to the RFP shall be made at the sole discretion of the city and the EDA. Ranking Criteria 1. Public Art Message – a maximum of 50 points What does the City of Elk River mean to you? The Economic Development Authority is seeking an impactful, memorable Project that communicates this concept to current and potential residents, businesses, and visitors. 7 2. Memorable and Impactful – a maximum of 20 points 3. Related Understanding – a maximum of 10 points a. Can the work be built and installed as proposed? b. Suitability of the artwork for outdoor display, including its maintenance and conservation requirements. c. Relationship of the artwork to the site and the host community, especially how it serves to activate or enhance economic development. d. Appropriateness of the scale of the artwork. e. How closely the proposed artwork meets the vision set out in the RFP and the Elk River Public Arts Plan . 4. Schedule - a maximum of 10 points a. Did the applicant meet all the required timelines? b. How well the proposed schedule from project initiation to final completion (including key tasks within each phase, key milestones and approximate dates, and deliverables) works for the city and EDA. c. Evidence of the artist’s ability to work collaboratively and successfully complete the Project on time and on budget. 5. Cost- a maximum of 10 points a. What are the city and the EDA’s costs in the short and long term? (1) Artists’ materials (2) Transportation costs (3) Installation costs (4) Future maintenance costs (5) Any other costs or charges 8 Section 6: Contract Terms and Conditions Prior to commencement of the Project, an agreement shall be entered into between the EDA and the artist(s). It is expected that the agreement will provide for compensation for actual work completed on a not to exceed basis and include at least the following conditions: Any changes to the RFP would be communicated to the registered artists. a. The EDA shall retain ownership of all renderings, mock ups, samples, photographs, drawing, and the Project prepared pursuant to the selected artist’s proposal. b. If, for any reason, the artist is unable to fulfill the obligations under the agreement in a timely and proper manner, the EDA reserves the right to terminate the agreement by written notice. In this event, the artist shall be entitled to just and equitable compensation for any satisfactory work completed to that point at the discretion of the EDA. c. The artist shall not assign or transfer any interest in the agreement without prior written consent of the EDA and city. Registration Due Date/Time October 4, 2019 4:00 p.m. (CST) Proposal Due Date/Time December 6, 2019 4:00 p.m. (CST) Late Submittals will not be considered. Public Art – Public Survey What public space in the City of Elk River would you like to see benefit from this project? 1. Parks/Trails 2. Sidewalks 3. Downtown 4. Gateway 5. Riverfront 6. Public Building 7. Other Is there a theme that this public art project should fall within? 1. Nature 2. Historical 3. Environment 4. Education 5. Other What would be your preferred style of art? 1. Sculpture 2. Monument 3. Statue 4. Street Furniture (benches, bike racks, etc.) 5. Mural 6. Other What would be your favored art medium used for this project? 1. Metal 2. Wood 3. Clay 4. Rock 5. Other City of Elk River Public Art Installation REGISTRATION FORM Deadline: October 4, 2019 at 4:00 p.m. CST The City of Elk River Economic Development Authority, Minnesota, seeks an artist or artist team to design, fabricate and install an exterior, permanent art feature within the City of Elk River. The public art installation will serve as a focal point of the city and will be tied visually and physically to the surrounding environment and communtiy. This significant public art installation will be highly visible to the community and tourists. The public art installation must complement the natural environment and define what the City of Elk River means to the artist. You must complete and submit this registration form to be eligible to submit a formal proposal. To obtain a copy of the Request for Proposals, contact Amanda Othoudt at 763.635.1042 or aothoudt@ElkRiverMN.gov Eligibility: The project is open to local artists who live within 100 miles of the City of Elk River. Any changes to the RFP will be communicated to the registered artists. There is no fee to submit this registration form. However, registration is mandatory to submit a subsequent proposal. No exceptions. If submitting this form by mail, it must be postmarked by October 1, 2019. Name Email Telephone Address By checking this box, I am confirming that I reside within 100 miles of the City of Elk River. Website Medium Signature Submission Options: City of Elk River Attention: Amanda Othoudt 13065 Orono Parkway Elk River, MN 55330 or aothoudt@ElkRiverMN.gov (type “Registration Form” in the subject line of the email) *DRAFT Review Deadlines: Rnd 1: Wed., July 22, 2020 Rnd 2: Wed., February 17, 2021 Application DEADLINES: Rnd 1: Wed., August 5, 2020 Rnd 2: Wed., March 10, 2021 BOARD Review: Rnd 1: Thurs., September 17, 2020 Rnd 2: Thurs., April 8, 2021 *DRAFT Review Deadlines: Thurs., September 10, 2020 Application DEADLINES: Thurs., September 24, 2020 PANEL Review: Fri., November 6, 2020 BOARD Review: Thurs., November 12, 2020 *DRAFT Review Deadlines: Rnd 1: Thurs., July 23, 2020 Rnd 2: Thurs., October 1, 2020 Rnd 3: Thurs., January 21, 2021 Rnd 4: Thurs., April 29, 2021 Application DEADLINES: Rnd 1: Thurs., August 6, 2020 Rnd 2: Thurs., October 15, 2020 Rnd 3: Thurs., February 11, 2021 Rnd 4: Thurs., May 13, 2021 BOARD Review: Rnd 1: Thurs., September 17, 2020 Rnd 2: Thurs., November 12, 2020 Rnd 3: Thurs., March 11, 2021 Rnd 4: Thurs., June 10, 2021 Application DEADLINE: Thurs., January 7, 2021 PANEL Review: Fri., February 26, 2021 BOARD Review: Thurs., March 11, 2021 Application DEADLINE: Thurs., February 25, 2021 PANEL Review: March 26 or 27, 2021 BOARD Review: Thurs., April 8, 2021 *DRAFT Review Deadlines: Rnd 1: Wed., July 15, 2020 Rnd 2: Wed., September 30, 2020 Rnd 3: Wed., February 17, 2021 Application DEADLINES: Rnd 1: Wed., July 29, 2020 Rnd 2: Wed., October 21, 2020 Rnd 3: Wed., March 17, 2021 PANEL Review: Rnd 1: Fri., September 11, 2020 Rnd 2: Fri., December 4, 2020 Rnd 3: Fri., April 23, 2021 BOARD Review: Rnd 1: Thurs., September 17, 2020 Rnd 2: Thurs., December 10, 2020 Rnd 3: Thurs., May 13, 2021 *DRAFT Review Deadlines: Rnd 1: Wed., July 22, 2020 Rnd 2: Wed., October 28, 2020 Rnd 3: Wed, March 24, 2021 Application DEADLINES: Rnd 1: Wed., August 5, 2020 Rnd 2: Wed., November 18, 2020 Rnd 3: Wed., April 7, 2021 BOARD Review: Rnd 1: Thurs., September 17, 2020 Rnd 2: Thurs., December 10, 2020 Rnd 3: Thurs., May 13, 2021 *DRAFT Review Deadlines: Rnd 1: Wed., August 12, 2020 Rnd 2: Wed, March 24, 2021 Application DEADLINES: Rnd 1: Wed., August 26, 2020 Rnd 2: Wed., April 7, 2021 BOARD Review: Thurs., October 8, 2020 Thurs., May 13, 2021 Biennial program offered again in Fiscal Year 2022 FISCAL YEAR 2021 GRANT CALENDAR Public Art Rnd 1 Teaching Artist Grant Rnd 4 Thursday, October 8, 2020 Thursday, November 12, 2020 Thursday, December 10, 2020 Thursday, March 11, 2021 Thursday, April 8, 2021 Thursday, May 13, 2021 Thursday, June 10, 2021 Teaching Artist Grant Rnd 2; Artist Career Development Organizational Development Rnd 2; Project Grant Rnd 2 Individual Artist Awards; Teaching Artist Grant Artist In Residence Rnd 2; Student Scholarship Organizational Development Rnd 3; Project Grant Rnd 3; Public Art Teaching Artist Roster Training Project Grant Organizational Development Grant ROLLING DEADLINE: Applications are reviewed and approved within 30 days of submission. Applications are accepted July 13, 2020 through May 28, 2021 of the Fiscal Year. Public Art Grant Community Arts Support - Biennial Grant Student Arts Scholarship Biennial program offered again in Fiscal Year 2022 Artist In Residence Artist Career Development Artist Learning Grant CMAB Teaching Artist Grant Individual Artist Award Board of Directors Meetings Meeting Dates: held at 2:30 pm Board Action: Thursday, September 17, 2020 Artist In Residence Rnd 1; Organizational Development Rnd 1; Teaching Artist Grant Rnd1; Project Grant Rnd 1