5.4. SR 08-08-2005
Item 5.4.
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Mayor and City Council
FROM:
Pat Klaers, City A~W~trator
August 8, 2005 it]
DA TE:
SUBJECT:
Discussion on Leasing/Renting of City Property
Councihnember I\lotin requested that this item be on a \vorksession agenda. The city 11as no
policy on record for dus type of situation, although there \vas a fair amount of discussion in
1999 regarding HRl\. o\vned property that is for sale.
_r\.ttaclled is some information Director of Planning NIicllele I:vlcPherson found \vlUle
researching this topic. ..Also attached is a memo from Parks and Recreation Director Bill
l\laertz regarding \VIlat transpired last winter \vith the tree sales at Emporium.
s: \ Council \ Pat\2005 \ \X! orksessions \LeasingCi ty Property .doc
MEMORANDUM
FROM:
Pat Klaers, City Administrator
Michele MCPherso~ctor of Planning
TO:
o ATE:
August 3, 2005
SUBJECT:
Use of Vacant Property
You requested that I research whether or not the City Council had established a policy
regarding the use of City property by either for-profit or non-profit entities.
Attachments
. April 19, 1999 City Council meeting minutes
. April 26, 1999 City Council meeting minutes
. May 24, 1999 City Council meeting minutes
. July 19, 1999 City Council meeting minutes
The last discussion the City Council had regarding the use of vacant City property occurred
in 1999 and related to HRA owned property located at the intersection of King Avenue and
Main Street. This lot is where First National Financial Center is now located.
At that time, the City Council passed a motion that prohibited use of HRA-owned property
that is currently for sale for any public or private use. Subsequent to that motion, in the
same year, the City Council allowed use of the lot for the Art Soup and the Heritage
Festivals. Since that time, the Art Soup Festival has utilized Jackson Square and the green
space which will soon become Rivers Edge Park in 2006.
In 2004, the Emporium site was used for Christmas tree sales by a private entity.
I found no other information relating to establishment of a policy for the use of City
property by for-profit or non-profit entities. If you have any further questions or need
further assistance, please contact me at Extension 1031.
S:\PL.tu"JNING\ivlichele IvlcPherson \lv[EivlOS\08 03 05 PK yacant prop.doc
City Council Minutes
April 1 9, 1 999
Page 18
.....-_....--~...........~..........~_...._....-----.-.IIIIIIII......,.....
e
Planning Commission Representative Louise Kuester indicated that this issue
emerged from the Comprehensive Plan for the city. She stated that the Plannin
Commission spent many hours researching and reviewing this issue. She furthe
noted that the ordinance would give property owners another opportunity d
option in the development of their land. She stated that this ordinance es not
require that land be given away for open space. She indicated that it' the
property owners choice whether or not to utilize clustering.
Mayor Klinzing indicated she would not want to adopt this typ f ordinance unless
there was a request from property owners or developers.
Councilmember Motin indicated that he would like to ar more from developers
regarding this issue.
There being no further comments from the pub' ,Mayor Klinzing closed the public
hearing.
COUNCILMEMBER MOTIN MOVED TO PO PONE THIS ISSUE INDEFINITELY.
COUNCILMEMBER THOMPSON SECO D MOTION. THE MOTION CARRIED 4-1.
Councilmember Farber opposed.
7.
Other Business
City Attorney Pete eck reviewed the status of the eminent domain process for the
eastern area pr ect and distributed a resolution relating to the Eull property. He
noted that t Eull property was excluded from the original resolution which was
adopted the council to begin the process.
e
COU ILMEMBER DIETZ MOVED TO ADOPT RESOLUTION 99-32 AUTHORIZING EMINENT
D AIN AND ACQUISITION OF REAL PROPERTY IN ACCORDANCE WITH MINN. STAT.
1.042. COUNCILMEMBER THOMPSON SECONDED THE MOTION. THE MOTION
CARRIED 5-0.
______...._......_.......IIIIIIII.......~IIIIIIII'-....~
Use of Vacant City Prooertv
Council member Motin questioned whether the city had a policy regarding the use
of vacant city property. He indicated that he was referring to the request to have
a car show on the HRA King and Main property. He noted that this type of use is a
profit making endeavor and questioned if the city should be involved by allowing
the use of its land. Councilmember Thompson questioned what the city's liability
was regarding these types of situations.
Council discussion pursued regarding the use of vacant city property. It was the
consensus of the City Council not to allow any type of private or public use of the
HRA property at King and Main street.
e
e
e
II
City Council Minutes
April 19, 1999
Page 19
COUNCILMEMBER THOMPSON MOVED TO NOT ALLOW USE OF HRA OWNED PROPERTY
THAT IS CURRENTLY FOR SALE FOR ANY PUBLIC OR PRIVATE USE. COUNCILMEMBER
DIETZ SECONDED THE MOTION. THE MOTION CARRIED 4...1. Councilmember Farber
opposed.
8.
Staff Uodates
There were no staff updates.
9. Adjournment
There being no further business, Mayor Klinzing adjourned the council meeting at
11 :03 p.m.
~ fJ~a#-
Sandra Peine
City Clerk
Joint City Council/Park and
Recreation Commission Minutes
April 261 1999
Page 2
e
4.0.
~~ Sf@U.r~
T any Darkenwald and David Raymondl representing the M ~1!~ Festival
Committeel asked the city to allow use of the King and Main HRA site for festival
activities. Ms. Darkenwald explained that two large tents would be placed on the
site to locate art demonstrations for various age groups. They also requested that
the city approve the closing of Jackson Avenue and King A venue for the ~iffi ~
Festival on June 26 and 27th. Ms. Darkenwald explained that booths will be located
in the city parking lot and along Jackson. The IIEnergy" stage will be located on
city property between the Cinema building and the Sunshine Depot. featuring a
variety of local talent.
Council member Dietz questioned why King Avenue is shown as being closed off on
their sketch. Mr. Raymond indicated that the committee felt it would provide a
safer situation for pedestrians going back and forth from the parking lot to the HRA
site exhibits.
COUNCJLMEMBER MOriN MOVED THAT, RECOGNIZING THE CITY COUNCIL'S
PREVIOUS MOTION TO PROHIBIT USE OF THE HRA SITE FOR SCHEDULED ACTIVITIES, TO
ALLOW USE OF THE MAIN AND KING FOR THE ARm mUE FESTIVAL ACTIVITIES ON A
"ONE TIME" BASIS, IN CONSIDERATION THAT TIME CONSTRAINTS Will NOT ALLOW
CHANGING THE LOCATION. COUNCILMEMBER FARBER SECONDED THE MOTION. THE
MOTION CARRIED 4.1. Councilmember Dietz opposed.
e
4. .
City AcceDtance of a Portion of County Ditch # 10
B . ding and Zoning Administrator Steve Rohlf indicated on a map the portion of
Ditc 1 0 that Sherburne County will be turning over to the City of Elk River as part
of the tern Area Improvements. Staff recommends the Council officially accept
this transfe .
COUNCILMEMBE OTIN MOVED TO ACCEPT THE TRANSFER OF THAT PORTION OF
SHERBURNE COUNTY TCH #10 TO THE CITY OF ELK RIVER, AS SHOWN ON THE
ATTACHED MAP, AND F HER, THAT THE COUNTY BE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE
OUTLETTING INTO THE REMA DER OF COUNTY DITCH #10. COUNCILMEMBER FARBER
SECONDED THE MOTION. THE liON CARRIED 5-0.
4.2.
e
Steve Rohlf explained problems with the ci ' current policy for erosion control
during new construction. He reviewed the pro sed revised policy, noting that
input was provided by developers, the Suburban rthwest Builders Association,
and the City Engineer. Steve indicated that staff is posing to require 2 rows of
sod around the entire perimeter of new developments, d silt fencing and rock
driveways will only be required on lots with a steep grade to e street. He further
proposed that the city's public works department will sweep tli streets on a
regular basis until a subdivision reaches 75% occupancy. The cos f sweeping the
streets will be paid by the developer. Steve indicated that the policy ill be
addressed through the developer's agreement for new plats. Existing pi will
continue to be addressed through the current policy. steve noted that the
Planning, Street and Building Departments have all endorsed the recommend
changes.
Elk River City Council Minutes
Mav 24. 1999
Page 5
e
4.2.
~m; ~1Uit} Festival Site Plan Review
Director of Planning Michele McPherson provided the Council with a site plan for
the layout of the ~ [m.m~ Festival. She noted that the site plan includes the
closing of King and Jackson Avenues. She indicated that it is proposed to close
Jackson Avenue from 6:30 a.m. on Saturday" June 26, to 7 p.m. Sunday" June 27"
1999. King Avenue will also be closed at the same times during the day, but will
be open on Saturday night. She further noted that the ~ftf ~~ Festival is
requesting approval from the city for the placement of three temporary
advertising signs on city property.
COUNCILMEMBER THOMPSON MOVED TO AUTHORIZE THE CLOSING OF KING AND
JACKSON AVENUES DURING THE TIMES PROPOSED FOR THE DfIl mum FESTIVAL.
COUNCILMEMBER FARBER SECONDED THE MOTION. THE MOTION CARRIED 5-0.
COUNCILMEMBER FARBER MOVED TO ALLOW THE THREE SIGNS ADVERTISING THE
FESTIVAL TO BE PLACeD ON CITY PROPERTY AS PROPOSED BY THE &t SBUB
FESTIV AL.
e
Discussion pursued regarding the possibility of setting a precedence regarding
the use of city property for festivals and placement of signs. It was noted by the
Council that the ~ m.g~~ Festival is an exception to the rule due to the fact that
they were well into the planning process and had assumed approval based on
receiving city funding and support prior to the Council making its decision to not
allow the use of city property for festivals or sign placement.
THE MOTION CARRIED 4-0-1. Council member Dietz abstained.
5.
Darre land, 13563 Island View Drive, indicated his concern regarding the
closing 0 e road in front of Cretex and the effect the closing has on the kids
living in the Is d View Addition. He indicated that there was no way for the kids
to walk into town ithout going on Highway 10.
The City Administrator in
regarding the closed road.
place of the road.
ed Mr. Island that staff is working with Cretex
indicated that there are plans to develop a trail in
6.1.
Assistant Director of Economic Development M Nevinski informed the Council
that a purchase agreement has been received in amount of $350,000 for the
Holt/Jackson parcel located on Highway 169. He indic ed that the buyer is
proposing to build a Denny's Restaurant on the site. He fu r indicated that
development of the site is contingent upon site plan and CUP roval by the
Planning Commission and City Council.
e
Council member Motin indicated that he would not approve the agreem
because he is uncertain as to whether there should be a restaurant on that si
Elk River City Council Minutes
Julv 19~ 1999
Page 2
e
4.1.
Coun' ember Thompson updated the Council on the progress of the Boys and
Girls Club. uncilmember Thompson noted the personnel committee is charged
with searching Boys and Girls Club program director.
4.2.
Council member Dietz updated the ncil on the issues discussed during the
June and July Utilities Commission Meetin
Mayor Klinzing provided an update on the Northstar Corridor elopment
Authority Meeting of July 1, 1999. Mayor Klinzing noted that there · e a
seoping meeting at the Sherburne County Courthouse on July 28, 4-7 p. The
purpose of the meeting is to gather comments from the public to determine
the corridor will impact the area.
4.3. Northstar Corridor Uodate
4.4.
Reauest to Use City Prooertv bv Heritaae Festival
e
City Clerk Sandy Peine indicated that the city has received a. request from the
Heritage Festival to use the city-owned property at King and Main street for
Heritage Festival activities. She noted that Mr. Ed Border, chairman of the
Heritage Festival, has requested use of the vacant lot for parking during the
festival on September 18 and 19.
Mr. Border addressed the council and indicated that he was just recently advised
that the Heritage Festival had already received permission from the city to use
the vacant lot on the corner of King and Main Street for parking. He noted that
children's games are scheduled to use the parking lot behind Kemper Drug. The
City Clerk noted that she was not aware that the Heritage Festival had received
permission from the council to use the vacant lot for parking.
The City Council discussed the issue. Councilmember Thompson noted that he
would prefer to see the vacant lot used for children's games rather than parking.
He noted that he did not want to close the parking area behind the businesses
during the festival. Mr. Border agreed that this was a good idea.
Councilmember Mann indicated that the council has already authorized by a
previous motion that city property not be used for public or private use. He
indicated that the council made one exception for the Arts Soup Festival and
stated that he feels it is not in the council's best interest to make another
exception.
e
Councilmember Dietz stated that he feels the council should make another
exception for this event as it is a community festival. He suggested that the
council approve an informal policy for the use of city property by community
events following council approval. Councilmember Thompson concurred and
stated that he felt the Heritage Festival is a community event held for the
Elk River City Council Minutes
Julv 19. 1999
Page 3
e
betterment of the community. Councilmember Farber concurred with
Councilmembers Dietz and Thompson.
COUNCILMEMBER FARBER MOVED THAT AN EXCEPTION BE MADE TO THE MOTION
OF APRIL 19,1999, MADE BY THE CITY COUNCil REGARDING THE USE OF HRA
OWNED PROPERTY CURRENTLY FOR SALE AND FURTHER TO ALLOW THE HERITAGE
FESTIVAL TO USE THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT THE CORNER OF KING AND MAIN STREET
ON SEPTEMBER 18 AND 19, 1999, FOR THE SPECIFIC USE OF CHILDREN'S GAMES.
Discussion was held by the council regarding Councilmember Motin's concem
whether the exception to the April 19 motion allowing the Heritage Festival to use
this property is a one time exception. . Councilmember Dietz suggested that a
policy be drafted by the Ci1y Clerk for council approval regarding the use of HRA
owned property. The Mayor indicated that this policy would be presented to the
council for consideration at a future council meeting.
COUNCILMEMBER DIETZ SECONDED THE MOTION. THE MOTION CARRIED 5-0.
.50. Uodate on Community Recreation Activities - Michele Bergh
Interim Community Recreation Director Michele Bergh updated the City Council
community recreation summer programs. She indicated that the
pro amming is going very well. She also updated the council on the Safety
Camp d showed a short video of activities that took place at the Safety
Camp.
e
4.5b. Discussion on C
Council member Matin dated the council on issues of discussion at the
Community Recreation B rd meeting. He indicated that the board has spent
much time discussing the thr options. He explained that the options are as
follows: a.) maintain the status 0 of the joint powers agreement; b.) the city of
Elk River beginning its own commu' recreation department; and c.) the
community education or school distri taking over the programming of
communiiy recreation. Council member atin indicated that there has been no
consensus of the Community Recreation Bo regarding these options.
Councilmember Mann questioned the council to their thoughts regarding
whether all three options are viable for the city of River.
Mayor Klinzing stated that if all three options were equal cost to the ci1y, it
would make the decision easier. She indicated that her to hoice is to go with
Option A followed by Option C as she feels this would be best the public and
she indicated she is not willing to rush into forming a parks depart nt.
Councilmember Dietz indicated his choice would include Option A or B.
stated he would rather see the joint powers stay as it is, but if he sees no
commitment from the other municipalities to continue, then he would be in fa r
of Option B.
Councilmember Thompson concurred with Council member Dietz.
e
MEMORANDUM
TO: Pat Klaers, City Administrator
FROM Bill Maertz, Director of Parks and Recreation
DATE: August 4, 2005
SUBJECT: Lease of Emporium Parking Lot
In October of 2004, I \vas contacted by a representative of Rum River Tree Farm \vho \vas
interested in using the parking lot at the Emporium/Old Northbound Liquor for their
Christmas tree sale. Because this space is being programmed by Parks and Recreation, I
assumed that it ,"vas a Parks Facility. Due to a change in Wal-rvrart cOlporate policy, Rum
River Tree was unable to locate at \Val-I:vlart last year and was looking for a new location.
I negotiated a lease price of $1,500 \vorth of balled and burlapped trees in exchange for use
of the west half of the parking lot.. Rum River Tree provided a letter of credit for $1,500.
Parks maintenance staff \vill be planting these trees in I<lie\Ter Point Park this fall as part of
the park development plan.