4.3. SR 07-19-1993
,
..
-, Iff
~
e
- / } ~ ~ ~ _./ J.. CONSULTING ENGINEERS
""".."" Maier Stewart & Associates Inc.
June 24, 1993 t/. 3 .
--
File No: 230-137-20
Mr. Pat Klaers
Administrator
City of Elk River
P. 0. Box 490
13065 Orono Parkway
Elk River, MN 55330
RE: ULTRAVIOLET DISINFECTION SYSTEM EQUIPMENT
WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT
Dear Mr. Klaers:
e
On Monday, June 21, 1993, we opened bids at the City Hall for the referenced wastewater
treatment plant equipment. The specifications were set up with a "pre-qualification"
requirement in order to evaluate manufacturers prior to the opening of bids. . We received
pre-qualification submittal from three (3) manufacturers and after review, two (2)
manufacturers were accepted as qualified. We have attached a copy of our summary of the
prequalification submittal for your reference.
At the bid opening we received bids from the two (2) companies which had pre-qualified and
the third company which we had originally rejected. The bids received were as follows:
1.
2.
Trojan Technologies, Inc.
Fisher & Porter, Ltd.
$ 89,600
$119,736
While the third bid is consider non-responsive, for your information purposes the amount
quoted by the manufacturer was $104,990.
Based on our review of the pre-qualification submittal, our discussions with operators using
similar Trojan equipment, and our experience with the Trojan equipment, during the pilot
study at your plant last year, we would recommend award of the contract to the lowest
qualified bidder, Trojan Industries, Inc. in the amount of $89,600.
. 137-2301.jun
9800 SHELARD PARKWAY, SUITE 102, MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55441 612-546-0432
1959 SLOAN PLACE, SUITE 200, ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55117 612-774-6021 . Equal Opportunity Employer
~ ,.
e
BID TABULATION
PROJECT: CONTRACT A - ULTRAVIOLET DISINFECTION EQUIPMENT
OWNER: CITY OF ELK RIVER
OPENNING DATE: JUNE 21,1993
ENGINEER: MAIER STEWART AND ASSOCIATES, INC.
ITEM ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT QUANTITY TROJAN TECHNOLOGIES ,INC. FISCHER & PORTER, lTD
NO. UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE UNIT PRICE TOTAL PRICE
($) ($) ($) ($)
1. U V DISINFECTION SYSTEM lS 1 89,600.00 89,600.00 119,736.00 119,736.00
------- -------
------- -------
TOTAL BID $89,600.00 $119,736.00
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS IS AN ACCURATE TABULATION
OF THE BIDS RECEIVED FOR THE ABOVE MENTIONED PROJECT.
e t1dP~~ -
NAME: YUYUEN (Bill) CHANG
DATE: JUNE21,1993
MN REG NO: 22610
e
!Ii
c
.. .. ... 0
CD CD !Ii :l .;:
-' :s .~ ... c 0 0
e <{ 0 ;;::
I- .r:~;z .,; .;: C .0
I- g~E::iE ~ a. Gl Gl
Gl .. a.
~ ~ .... a. .E .,; 0 ..
.Q ._, X ..
III .5'~5-~ Gl .. ...
.Q Gl CIl
::> ... ~
".S: W::iE :l ... 0 CIl
m .. .E c E E
Z "' 0 c ..
];'So-g t:: .Q " :l S
<{ :l ~ "M .,; .,;
..., 0- ... ta 0 .. CO) "
~.o1- a. ~ ~ ~
0 o."GlZ Gl .. ~O) Gl
a: ~!;:E a: ~ lii ,,- .E .E ffi
I- '" ~ .. . CD
o ~ ~ "C~ .0 r- .0 .0 a.
.g =0- :l :l a.
~ 0 .. .. ..
-aCD:l]! Gl .. CD Gl
~~.r::C Gl .... .... X c t:: t:: t::
c 0 :l .. :l 0 0 0
.J2".~ t:: .;::;' ... c ~..., a. a. a.
o c.r: 0 c .. .. <{ g CD CD CD
u..~Z W :.::; ::iE a: a: a:
I-
Z
W
::iE
[l.
5
o
W
::iE
W
I-
m
>-
m
Z
o
i=
U
W
Ll..
Z
en
o
>
::>
a:
W
>
a:
:.<:
-'
W
a:
o
Ll..
m
-'
<{
l-
I-
~
III
::>
m
Z
o
i=
<{
U
u:
::;
<{
::>
o
W
g:
Ll..
o
>-
a:
<{
::iE
::iE
.~
e
-'
<{
l-
I-
~
III
::>
m
a:
W
I-
a:
o
[l.
a:
W
J:
U
m
u:
c ~
.. .S!
... >
"Vi 0
'> +or
S~
:a:c
.. .. 0
o ._
CD ~...
~ U ..
CD .. ~
~-'8.
CD .S; 0
~ c.s;
lii ~ E
> .. CD
CD-'"
~ c;; ..
:>... >-
o .. ..
J: .S; ..
-'
<{
l-
I-
~
III
::>
m
:.<:
W
I-
<{
a:
I-
-'
::>
s
"
e
CD
.<!:
-c~M
.!cnO)
.~ Q) 0)
E.o '":.
.o:lr-
:l"'_
: ~ ~
-[.~ :t
..~...,
g>>'2 .~
""::1:::
0_0
-a~<{
~~~
m
I-
Z
W
::iE
W
a:
5
o
W
a:
Z
o
i=
<{
U
u:
U
W
[l.
m
e' E
~~
~~
cm
w"
~ i
liji
Ill...
, c
Gl Gl
"5 0
"c
o 0
::iE.g ~
>:f!~
:::>~Q)
bOU
0....0
~~~
~~8
~
M
<
<'!
o
N
M
'<t
::iE
W
!::
"
CD
...
...
.E
.Q
:l
..
..
t::
o
a.
Gl
a:
'"
c
.~
CD
C
.;::;'
C
W
"
CD
....
...
.E
.0
:l
..
..
.r:
a.
..
0,
S
o
.r:
a.
o
Z
~
e
.:l
...
o
..
'5
c
.. .r:"
E .1: ~
>- .....S; ~ Gl
ffig;t::"~
.5 6-~~1O
E Gl Gl.- .
:::~~E'<t
.~-g-g.g~
-g:;-crno
,t; 0 ~~~~
~~e-S:!22
:]._",o...,:J......
..i;C~o.E
U)'-ca...,~.c
t:: "'c;;".1::l
0.5::: CD "C CIJ
O'~.-'lilcc;;
~ 0 Eo.. E
o~.g:o~1..
zu..cn.E;;;~
a;
>
CD
-'
0""
;0
.. ..
Ea:
o '"
'5.5
<{la
.:J.!!
oU
~-g
~~
o.Gl
0.=
~,g
> g
::>U
-'!
<'l
<{
<'!
o
N
M
'<t
, ui
b ..' ~ g
m .g '4J i-'~
~.!! g == "5
Q)Gi;~..s:!
"C~~t;~
.'n;~.!-g
!"5n;b~
=.~~~.~
5~ta~a.
lS-8.-g.5 ~
.....!!?: ca en U)
~"'::f~b
'~::VlO)rn
~.J2~.S;"8
.~,;=c-g..c
C):Jm(j;
Jji5..~.S; E
.t
<
<'!
o
N
M
'<t
"
2
....
.E
.0
:l
..
..
Gl
~
.0
..
....
b
....
..
:.::;
~
Gl
"
o
lii
:::
..
c;;
en 0 Q;
~ .c >
tl 1i a:
~.~~.! ~
'5 tV. E CD ~ 0
.~ ~ ......5.:.c c: 'to-
cn'~~w.!.~-g
.9!c..~~f!o~
gQ)~"C5.cg.
~].c::g"C~Q.
::~~EE~1U
o.l:~c~...r:
+-'::>000)....
~ ~g~:~~
".o-c~.o:::
.!"Ocnca...,cacn
.1:~E"o.""E
~'>~~5~~
~ ~~~t5.= ~
c '"
~.g c ~
i ~ Om.a
a.'CG3g
..., ._.c._
;:6~-g1:
E>o'jij~
1a:::>CDt):J
~ .! -S .6 ~
.- U) C C ",j
~.E:~co4i
....E.og;.o
~-UCDCDEE
cn:ctii;cu:J
b ~ ~.r: ; ~
C)..c0"'C'-C
.S;.~E.21So
~..c.!'o~-a
.- ~ .. CD Gl Gl
:;C.S; ~g.g.~
It)
<
N
ci
N
M
'<t
..
c
.2
Q.
Gl
o
X
Gl
c;;
lii
>
Gl
.."
-g ~
~.~
Gi ~
:; ~
g ~
~~
...r:
::iE ~
.gB
.. c
= Q)
~-'"
Gl ..
~...
:l ..
g 5
'5+:;
la lS-
E ~ !Ii
Gl C
go~
: ~ .2
co::
CD'~ ~
~.~ g.
... Gl
.." Gl
t;>-~
<{la-s
co
<
<'!
o
N
M
'<t
g!
.E ~
(ij~
lii Gl
> CD
m Q)
" ~
.!ae
.. 0
::: 1: .
~~~
B~o.
1;l.2 ~
'$o.g
c~"
:E ~ la
...
:l
o
C
Gl
..
..
..
~
E
:l
'g~
~O)
,,-
.. r-'
~';
~ c
.. :l
.......,
~g
...
:l
o
....
C
CD
..
..
..
~
E
:l
-g~
~O)
,,-
..,..:
. -
-g~
~ :l
.......,
~g
~
Gl
CD B
Gl 0
.S; ..
'" ....
;g>~E
Gl.;:E~i
= ~ 'c i
:2E~.E~
.0-6 E CD.=
~ ~.g.-S 5-
~:g 5-'i!
o cu CD:: c
~c>:S.2
cu<<l::J.....1O
" ~ ~ CD.~
It):g:g~~
.S;.- o..r: :l
.r:=GlOlT
~~g.;e
>cnCU>Q.
":
<{
<'!
o
N
(')
'<t
"
Gl
...
...
.E
.0
:l
..
t::
o
a.
Gl
a:
" Gl
~.Q
.1: "'C
E:i
.0 0
:l~L
.. ..
Gl CD....
~ :: .~
Gl.r: E
~....Q
.. " :l
t:: CD ..
8.1ViU
~ ~ E
c 0
0-= :-
.. .. ..
10 .;; .....
" E 0
.ot::
o :l ..
Z m a.
.. !3
~ ~ ~
a: CD >
... >
E g lii
.c ._ 0
::J 10 ~
.. ~ ...
cvc~
ii~~
CD u E
a ~ ~
~ "0 en
.... Gl ..
E~-g
EC.~ai
~~~E
t- "'C 0;:; ';i
~
<{
<'!
o
N
M
'<t
"
Gl
...
...
.E
.0
:l
..
t::
o
a.
Gl
a:
" CD
Gl.o
...
.'t::: "'C
E"5
.0 0
iil~'n;
CD Gl...
Gi ~.~
~-S.o
.." :l
t:: CD ..
g,1VC6
!:aE
'0 .E~
cv 10 cv
10 .~ .....
"C E 0
o.g i
Z m a.
gE~
CD Gl 0
ct;1U~
~~.8!
~ ~.!2 00
~"in"'O ~
>-==.~ CD
:~~-S
-:;~~B
.2.+-' ..... ""0
.o'Oi!
="ii] .1:
0" CD E
.. 0 0..0
.l:E~iil
:l" c
~~'~.8
~ ~ ;.~
1-...0..
C7!
<{
<'!
o
N
M
'<t
..
c
:8
.g
.0
Gl
a.
..
...
CD
CD
E
S
"
CD
ffi
Gl
a.
a.
..
t::
o
a.
CIl
a:
"CD
Gl.o
...
.~"'C
E"5
.Q 0
iil~'n;
Gl CD ...
Gi=~
~-S.o
.." :l
t:: CD ..
g,1Uca
e ~ E
'0.5 ~
CO a; cu
1U.~ ....
" E 0
.ot::
o :l ..
Z m a.
... ....
c .....
CD >- ~~
E::: .. ...
0."0.0.. E
~ ~ ~ tn'" ~ ~
i;:Cb~~~
"C ~ E.!.1! ~ :
CD+-'::JCD1::-
-S"EEOl'l
.5 ~:5 ~~~
"..ECD~"5
~~-cu-S.!!';
:::J:; ~ C).~=
'cuco.51Uc
:lo.r::!;!E.-
.....1-=-.;:;0"0
C/)a:~~'5~
.!~VJ~coo
Gl...tlE"g.
~o.!.!!fiQ.
o
<
<'!
o
N
M
'<t