9.4. SR 09-20-1993
r\.1 ~(
( II
ey11,
E ~ River
ITEM 9.4.
TO:
MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL
STEVEN B. ACH, CITY PLANNER~
FROM:
DATE: SEPTEMBER 20, 1993
SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST
BY WILLIAM PALMER/PUBLIC HEARING,
CASE NO. CU 93-24
ISSUE
William Palmer is requesting a conditional use permit to
construct a detached accessory building exceeding 1,000 sq ft
in area and having a total of 1,408 sq ft of accessory garage
space.
LOCATION OF REQUEST
11712-200 Avenue NW (Lot 3, Block 2, Brentwood), Elk River, MN.
ANALYSIS
e
The proposed garage would be 32'x44' (1,408
on the lot meeting all RIa setback
architectural design and exterior materials
existing home.
sq ft) and located
requirements. The
will compliment the
Mr. Palmer
store these
windows would
garage.
collects classic cars and would use the garage to
classic vehicles. For security purposes, no
be installed nor will there be a driveway to the
There were no residents in the audience
however, staff received a telephone
resident who expressed opposition.
opposing the request,
call from a neighboring
PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION
The Planning Commission unanimously recommend approval of the
conditional use permit for William Palmer allowing a 1,408 sq
ft detached accessory building in an RIa zoning district with
the following condition:
1. THE GARAGE MAINTAIN THE SAME ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN AND
EXTERIOR MATERIAL AS THE EXISTING HOME.
2. A TREE PRESERVATION PLAN BE SUBMITTED ALONG WITH THE
BUILDING PERMIT MINIMIZING THE LOSS OF EXISTING TREES.
-
P.O. Box 490 · 13065 Orono Parkway · Elk River, MN 55330 · (612) 441-7420 · Fax: (612) 441-7425
rei -\)
( );
!flll
')
)
ITEM 6
@@/lJJI!
TO:
PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM:
STEVEN B. ACH, CITY PLANNE~~
DATE: AUGUST 18, 1993
SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST
BY WILLIAM PALMER/PUBLIC HEARING,
CASE NO. CU 93-24
REQUESTED ACTION
A conditional use permit to construct
building exceeding 1,000 sq ft in area and
1,408 sq ft of accessory garage space.
a detached accessory
having a total of
LOCATION OF REQUEST
11712-200 Avenue NW (Lot 3, Block 2, Brentwood), Elk River, MN.
ZONING/LAND USE
RIa (Single Family Residential)/ LR (Low Density Residential)
ATTACHMENTS
.
Location Map, Zoning Map, Survey of Property, property Owners
List.
ANALYSIS
Mr. Palmer is in the process of purchasing an existing home in
the Brentwood development. Lots in Brentwood are generally 2
(plus or minus) acres in size and mostly wooded. Approximately
one half of Mr. Palmer's lot is encumbered by a Northern States
Power utility easement. Therefore, locating a site for the
proposed garage was limited to the front one half of the
property.
The location of the proposed 32' x 44' (1,~08 sq ft) garage
meets all RIa setback requirements for accessory structures.
Mr. Palmer plans on using the garage to store classic cars,
which he collects. There will be no windows for secruity
purposes and since there will be infrequent access to the
garage, no driveway will be installed.
Finally, the garage will compliment the home by maintaining the
same architectural design and exterior siding.
e
P.O. Box 490 · 13065 Orono Parkway · Elk River, MN 55330 · (612) 441-7420 · Fax: (612) 441-7425
e
e
e
\
~
CUP, William Palmer
August 18, 1993
Page 2
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended the Planning Commission recommend approval of
the conditional use permit for William Palmer allowing a 1,408
sq ft detached accessory building in an RIa zoning district
with the following condition:
1. THE GARAGE MAINTAIN THE SAME ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN AND
EXTERIOR MATERIAL AS THE EXISTING HOME.
" \
\ .
I \
II ,~" .~
LI" "
u
AFFECT~
PROPE'1 y
z
ci
a:
o
u
20lST
z
...
CI)
It)
Z
<(
N
.-.~
..
LOCATION MAP
I-\.(
e(
City of ~
Ell{
CASE CU '13 ~24
~
@
.
-. .
13065 Orono Parkway · Elk River. MN 55330 . (612) 441-7420
,..
e
e
~ty of ~
~ll{
.~
rl, i II 'L~ I_~.I
I}t.~'1 'I ~ I=_____
I_t'i_., I _ I ' I .
"l-
Ii' I I i I-"~r ! I I ~ -
-
, 1111_..1
!I~~'
:i~
K~~ ,
!~ "~\ /, ~,~~(L, ~
, ", I.,J t . .,
'.../ : \ '/1 ... .~
~ ~t-\, i'~. . n ,
, :-"j'~~/ : ~>~ = ' : ~ .' ~. ~I
~/ t~O .I
)' I . I J' r-- --: 't~(\\;. ~
: ~N' ..,"'.- I ~ ...,.' ... A, 2 2t.,". ., 's~c tOr
I ./........~./ J....... ~ '
;:'111 i fl. ~/RSr. HL=,~~'I' ..l~'1 ;:.~\\-; . '~~=1 -'. !: -, ! rr. I
v::.;::-;,./ "D~: I ' 'f .1. .1' , JF .1'-... ",T 6.:. .
:pF L't I.~' 0 .' ---; 'Il~- '\ \ ~ " 'I"
~~ f--/. ~t . _ \ \. \. II ~
~. I ".....~. . ~ "" '~\ \ I 't;';} ,
'\.1 I' . ,-(f~'" =
. 7ll'-:G~--' ' T
'm,I.T:\',,' ~ R1e
.JIO"r~. 'I -.'
JI t;;~r~:I.\i IM...:~J;;"
~~[2:~~~r: "\~, ~ ,:,.
" H{ 6\~~ oN. ~. , m r::-.:-:r I~ . /
J9'ST !! ~~c ~ ';'r.'~~ R~ '~~:;~~.-
'~ R~ ,'.~ .
.t ....yt.,.. ,-_'
,. , .' ~ l'PU 0'
-. ~ . ~ -
R4., ~,\
. ," R2b ~. '! ~..~' I " . ~l\ R1c
'qj~ 'W;-.;.!...f:;.! ~ l\
f-R3 ilEfU', ~'<...l..cjftj R2b ~\
::i ,=:r_~'~ .';#''''~ j
.,
~~-
12
I
I
r -
I
, 1 .....I! ~ n
., i I r- ",~ H
!/ ..\,;. ,,11
:11 ~ t I"';':s _ .'. ' ~
PHt}J ) ') :.
~~'" '. U I,
w ", .=1 J<a!.
""i "i.'~1\J
f-:j "~+ R1 a
- I
11.~r--j;'"
. 'L.l.;.. ~
-
('0 1IIr" H
~ 'R1c
ME !
RIa
~
\"
~\
, L..
-~
- o~..
,,1~'t''''Oo.
...,1. ~ o,.'i-
~ Er"" ~
~I ---'
~ ".
~ J
:) MT
'T'
I ~
~ ,
. -.l .
-,
.", H:"0:L II:" ~~;","
~ . 1lO,.~..; , / t-'
~.., " :L-
." "" ~
, 1~ ~r:= IE:[
~, .. .,l-'--'-
. -I I IW.-, I~:~~
:t~ ~' ~
.
-.
. ~ +;
~ ';"'TM" :>,~y .
ZONING MAP
j~
[1
~ I'lood!>IeJr>
[A1] 1qk:ulb.nl eon..n.Uat
li:ffiil SInQM F....uy RMIcIonU.I
~ SlnllIe F....uy R.-.u.l
IRi9 SlnllIe F....uy Re.IclontW
~ ~ F~y R.ldonlW
IBi!l SIngle FwnIIy IMIdenlIooI
~
@
/ .
(@ Two FwnIy ~...- -..
~ -r- FomIIy ~.
~ TowMouM/MulllpM FanlIy Reeld.nllal
~ MuIlIpIe FemIIy Ileald...u.l
~ Pl..--d \)1Il o...~
[gJ c...- C<<rmen:W
[gJ Olllce CloIrlct
~ HIgnw.y Comm.n:IaI
ill] Uv/lt Indust1W
@] Medbn industrial
~ Sold w..te Felty
IAIJ AIMnn8 T_
[Mgj ......... E=rwallon
A_
CU 9E>-2~
.....
CASE
River
P.O. Box 490 · 13065 Orono Parkway · Elk River, MN 55330 . (612) 441-7,420
Ffle Number
. ., .
PRLM,-_ )
\
Exhibit: A
e
DRAINAGE & UTILITY
EASEMENTS
U"3 8~c-A-~
aooT_Jt AV€... N.W.
jC}B./B -_
"'I
:;,.
1
I
,
'~
'D l:)J \.0..(-
h~ ~ C()
4,
"
~
.to
<='.s-
"1.t}-
'{)
o
''I
....~
$-0
'"
,
..J
-
^"
tuo p~ 'Ol~cuy<
~
"
"l,
~
"We hereby certify that we have made an inspection of the property herein
described, and that this plat shows the location of the improvemehts thereon
and that there are no encroachments unless ihdicated thereoh. Thia ~lat and
certificate are for mortgage pUrposes only."
Ay.'nt lOT
.
vVright Title Guarantee Co.
429 East Main Street
P.O. Box 390
Elk River. Minnesota 55330
(612) 441.5465
s
Suncllt\l 01 Contro( I
STEWART TITLE
GUARANTY COMPANY
W~ight Title Gua~antee Co. doe~ i,8r.~by Gectify that the following
list ~ep~esents all of the owners and thei~ addresses for properties
within 350 feet of Lot 3~ Block 2~ Br.entwood to wit:
A.Lot l~ Block 3~ Brentwood
Kent & Jeanne Peabody
11713 - 200th Avenue No~thwest
Elk River~ MN 55330
I.Lot 8~ Block 2~ B~entwood
Richa~d & Diane Heu~ing
11769 B~entwood Lane
Elk Rive~~ MN 55330
B.Lot 2~ Block 3~ B~entwood
Timotny & Joan B~untmyer
20028 Irving Street No~thwest
Elk River~ MN 55330
C.Lot l~ Block 2~ Brentwood
Richard & Mary 'Scott
20026 Jackson Circle Northwest
Elk River~ MN 55330
D.Lot 2~ Block 2~ B~entwood
I~ai & Rosalie Ezati
4It 19498 Lowell Street No~thwest
Elk Rive~~ MN 55330
J.Lot 9~ Block 2~ B~entwood
Lynn & Signe Caswell
11801 B~entwood Lane
Elk Rive~~ MN 55330
K.Lot l~ Block 4~ Brentwood
Ki~k & Pat~icia Woodfill
11620 - 201st Avenue No~thwest
Elk River~ MN 55330
L.Lot 2~ Block 4~ B~entwood
BLitt & Jill Procto~
19995 Irving Avenue No~thwest
Elk Rive~~ MN 55330
E . Lot 4 I, E 1 0 c k
Scott F~ase~
1167B - ?OOth
Elk Ri ve~ I) MN
2/. B~entwood
,
M.Lot 3~ Block 4~ Brentwood
Samuel & Melody Donelson
19963 I~ving Avenue Northwest
Elk River~ MN 55330
Avenue Northwest
55330
F.Lot 5~ Block 2~ B~entwood
I~aj & Rosalie Ezati
19498 Lowell Street Northwest
Elk River~ MN 55330
G.Lot 6~ Block 2~ B~entwood
Iraj & Rosalie Ezati
19498 Lowell Street Northwest
Elk River~ MN 55330
H.Lot 7~ Block 2~ Brentwood
Tom & Bernice Follmer
11721 Brentwood Lane
Elk River~ MN 55330
4Itwright Title Guarantee Co.
MlMBER Of THl AMERICAN lAND TITLE ASSOCIATION
MEMBERS Of THE MINNESOTA lAND TITlE ASSOCIATION
49